Grassroots Commentary
The Real Way to Prevent Shootings
There are two ways to think of gun ownership: one can think of the ubiquitous armed citizen as analogous to knowing CPR, or one can think of him/her as analogous to a fire extinguisher everywhere in the home. I like both of these, and they concentrate on the solution, not the dead-end handwringing over the crisis.
When we talk about whether the Aurora shooting could have been prevented, we need to think in terms of the incident's event horizon, let's say. That is to say, when the incident itself first appears and may seem inescapable with its own gravitational pull and point of no return.
Gun owners -- 90 million of them -- believe that you can never prevent a shooting massacre. But then, one can also not prevent a sudden death heart attack nor a kitchen grease fire entirely; instead, we attend to them in an educated, planned response when they appear, because they do appear.
We keep several fire extinguishers around the house so that at least one will be ready and within reach should a fire erupt. We keep our CPR training with us wherever we go should we witness a choking incident at a restaurant or a near-drowning. Because they do appear.
Though we cannot really fight a fire until it ignites, and though we cannot thump someone's chest until they need us, so the active shooter may not be noticed until they act. Like the choking victim, the active shooter begins and is noticed then and there. [If you want to talk about earlier signs such as a suspicious trenchcoat-wearing patron, then you're talking about the edge of your event horizon, aren't you?]
Like the grease fire and the cardiac arrest, the active shooter might not have been prevented, but can certainly be stopped.
Thinking in terms of prevention is a trap of the anti-gun crowd. The carping, framing their issue, and the smear of their hounding for the impossible is purely to needle everyone from candidates to taxpayers and non-taxpayers. Asking the impossible does not reflect ignorance, but savvy. It is the public who is ignorant if they bite down on the bait of an impossible idealistic rhetoric.
We will never prevent earthquakes ... er, active shooters, I mean; but we can be much, much better prepared for them.
Don't ban guns. It's a trap. The idea of preventing shootings is much more in the ubiquitous armed citizen than any other concept.
John Longenecker is author of The CPR Corollary. Better outcomes in the wider acceptance of gun ownership can mean smaller government in 2012.
6 Comments
wjm in Colorado
Wednesday, July 25, 2012 at 1:31 PM
The brain dead liberals will be with us also, and can't be prevented, with the advanced state of the ministry of propoganda and the dept of indoctrination, we almost have too many to counter.
Longenecker in Los Angeles
Wednesday, July 25, 2012 at 2:20 PM
Hi, WJM.
Liberals can be prevented. We unseat them in November.
Ted R. Weiland in Nebraska
Thursday, July 26, 2012 at 9:52 AM
For a Scriptural defense of of weapons, see "Firearms: Scripturally Defended" at http://www.missiontoisrael.org/firearm-right.php.
Larry Pratt, Executive Director of Gun Owners of America, believes our principle authority for bearing weapons in defense of ourselves, families, and others comes from the Bible, not the Second Amendment. You can hear his thoughts concerning this at http://www.missiontoisrael.org/tapelist.php#goa.
Adrien Nash in Crescent City, CA
Tuesday, July 31, 2012 at 4:08 AM
Massacres by perpetrators who are not suicidal can be prevented via the instilling of fear of painful consequences. I'm talking about real pain, as in half a dozen people with bullwhips having at him, followed by a half dozen more with hands full of darts, followed by half a dozen more with quivers full of arrows. televise that and see if such a massacre never happens again. Or you could just toss him to cold-blooded murderers in a maximum security prison and loan them all pairs of brass knuckles. Of course we'd have to suspend the constitutional ban on cruel and unusual punishment, which should be easy after Chief Judas roberts showed us how to simply change the meaning of words and then whatever you want to do in perfectly constitutional.
Mad Mac in Socialist State of California
Friday, August 3, 2012 at 1:32 PM
1) I've sent this to all 51 Patriots that signed the warning to oba mao and as many anti 2nd Amendment oaf-icials as I could find. Sadly, I'm STILL sending.
Senator, Thank you for honoring your Oath of Office to Protect, Preserve, and Defend our Constitution and sovereignty against the UN's ATT. YOU are a true Patriot. Unfortunately my own Senators dishonored their Oaths. So I respectfully submit this to you:
Proposal of New Legislation
Our new right, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA), was signed into law by President Obama and was upheld by the Supreme Court.
Since the U.S. government can now compel people to exercise rights, here is another right we URGENTLY need to protect.
I hereby propose the following legislation and urge members of Congress to quickly pass it into law. Below I describe the Shooter Protection And Realistic Training Act (SPARTA), informally referred to as Guncare. The heart of this bill is an individual mandate requiring every American to purchase firearms, ammunition and training.
Free men and women are recognized by their God-given human right to protect themselves and those weaker. Unlike the right to healthcare, The "Right to Bear Arms" is a genuine God-given human right, ALREADY guaranteed by the 2nd Amendment of the United States Constitution.
Guncare addresses the problem of inadequate access to affordable firearms, training and ammunition to support these human rights.
There are millions of Americans who don’t have access to adequate training and firearms. They count on the Police and righteous Citizens to protect them. This unfairly places the burden and costs of protecting our civilization on a tiny few. Because of this uneven distribution of responsibility, the cost of guns and ammunition is unreasonably high. If everyone is required to have a gun, ammunition, and adequate training, exercising our firearms human rights would be affordable for everyone.
Mad Mac in Socialist State of California
Friday, August 3, 2012 at 1:32 PM
2)There would, of course, be exemptions for Religious beliefs or financial hardship. Convicted felons, sex offenders and other liberals would be required to pay a fair tax which would be used provide free guns to the poor.
The costs in human misery of poor self-defense can no longer be condoned by society. If we can stop just one rape or child abduction with this law, it will all be worthwhile. The bill will also provide for a Federal concealed carry right for any adult without a criminal record or a mental illness.
According to Gallup polls, 47% of American adults currently report that they have a gun in their home or elsewhere on their property. This is up from 41% a year ago and is the highest Gallup has recorded since 1993. This is a good start.
The US Census population clock estimates there are 313,810,389 people in America. By my calculations, there are about 150 million people in America who are not exercising this most fundamental human right.
Let’s protect human rights everywhere they are endangered. It is the right thing to do. Think of the children. SUPPORT GUNCARE!
Feel free to copy/paste/edit/whatever trips your trigger, and send it EVERYWHERE, especially your Senators and other elected officials (oaf-icals if anti 2nd Amendment). Maybe something will stick.
http://www.usa.gov/Contact/Elected.shtml