Grassroots Commentary
What Gay Rights Activists Don't Want You to Read
Vital testimony from a man raised by two moms
Writer and assistant professor of English, Robert Lopez was raised by his mother and her female partner. His story about growing up without the gender cues most of us take for granted is vitally important and especially relevant now as America debates whether or not same-sex marriage benefits children.
Lopez relates his journey from his "lesbian mom's trailer," to college, to the "gay underworld," to cleaning out the Bronx apartments where men died of AIDS, to marriage to a woman and his commitment to "concern myself first and foremost with my children's needs, not my sexual desires."
Lopez says most people with same-sex attraction "don't realize what a blessing it was to be reared in a traditional home" where gender mores were learned naturally.
This story is a must-read. Lopez writes with wisdom, passion, and poetry. He has first-hand experience of growing up in gender confusion.
As America debates pro-gender marriage versus anti-gender marriage, it is crucial to remember it is not just about sexual orientation. Marriage is about gender, where biology and sociology intersect.
Excerpts from The Public Discourse:
After my mother's partner's children had left for college, she moved into our house in town. I lived with both of them for the brief time before my mother died at the age of 53. I was 19. In other words, I was the only child who experienced life under "gay parenting" as that term is understood today.
Quite simply, growing up with gay parents was very difficult, and not because of prejudice from neighbors. People in our community didn't really know what was going on in the house. To most outside observers, I was a well-raised, high-achieving child, finishing high school with straight A's.
Inside, however, I was confused. When your home life is so drastically different from everyone around you, in a fundamental way striking at basic physical relations, you grow up weird. I have no mental health disorders or biological conditions. I just grew up in a house so unusual that I was destined to exist as a social outcast.
My peers learned all the unwritten rules of decorum and body language in their homes; they understood what was appropriate to say in certain settings and what wasn't; they learned both traditionally masculine and traditionally feminine social mechanisms.
Even if my peers' parents were divorced, and many of them were, they still grew up seeing male and female social models. They learned, typically, how to be bold and unflinching from male figures and how to write thank-you cards and be sensitive from female figures. These are stereotypes, of course, but stereotypes come in handy when you inevitably leave the safety of your lesbian mom's trailer and have to work and survive in a world where everybody thinks in stereotypical terms, even gays.
I had no male figure at all to follow, and my mother and her partner were both unlike traditional fathers or traditional mothers. As a result, I had very few recognizable social cues to offer potential male or female friends. . . . Gay people who grew up in straight parents' households may have struggled with their sexual orientation; but when it came to the vast social universe of adaptations not dealing with sexuality -- how to act, how to speak, how to behave -- they had the advantage of learning at home. Many gays don't realize what a blessing it was to be reared in a traditional home.
Life is hard when you are strange.
When I got to college, I set off everyone's "gaydar" and the campus LGBT group quickly descended upon me to tell me it was 100-percent certain I must be a homosexual. When I came out as bisexual, they told everyone I was lying and just wasn't ready to come out of the closet as gay yet. Frightened and traumatized by my mother's death, I dropped out of college in 1990 and fell in with what can only be called the gay underworld. Terrible things happened to me there. I am a bisexual Latino intellectual, raised by a lesbian, who experienced poverty in the Bronx as a young adult. I'm perceptive enough to notice that liberal social policies don't actually help people in those conditions. Especially damning is the liberal attitude that we shouldn't be judgmental about sex. In the Bronx gay world, I cleaned out enough apartments of men who'd died of AIDS to understand that resistance to sexual temptation is central to any kind of humane society. Forty-one years I'd lived, and nobody -- least of all gay activists -- had wanted me to speak honestly about the complicated gay threads of my life. If for no other reason than this, Mark Regnerus deserves tremendous credit -- and the gay community ought to be crediting him rather than trying to silence him.
How ironic that gay rights activists that encourage kids to come Outright and who sponsor the Day of Silence to combat prejudice are now trying to silence scientific inquiries such as the Regnerus study and people with street cred such as Robert Lopez.
Do yourself a favor and read Lopez' entire gripping story at The Public Discourse.
Defend pro-gender marriage.
Frances Kelly lives in Vermont and writes for Homegriddle and Conjugality.
21 Comments
Marco Luxe in Los Angeles, CA
Thursday, August 9, 2012 at 5:21 PM
Your headline is deliberately misleading, i.e. a lie.
The subheadline "Vital testimony from a man raised by two moms" is contradictied by a direct quote from Mr. Lopez, "I lived with both of them for the brief time" [only as an adult (19)].
norman in los angeles
Thursday, August 9, 2012 at 5:24 PM
OK, one story-that took place decades ago!-there are MILLIONS of stories of kids being raised by abusive straight parents! All studies show that gay parents are just as good if not better parents than straight ones-every study. This one person account is meaningless. The Regernus report has been debunked as flawed by EVERYONE-it had two same sex couples-thats it-the other ones were gay people who married straight people and tehn broke up-of course divorce impacts kids-All kids need is LOVE-from one parent, two parents, two moms, two dads, etc. Nice try bigot!
TruthInAction in Telephone, TX
Friday, August 10, 2012 at 8:12 AM
He is no less "meaning"less than your "mean" and unjustified remarks. Please, remember there are always, at least, always, three perspectives, yours, theirs, and others. Yours just happens to be different than his, but attacking and calling his remarks bigotry is not appropriate and de"means" your opinion.
Mike Thomas in Des Moines Iowa
Saturday, August 11, 2012 at 9:00 PM
Sorry Norman but Having Gay Parents is NOT Normal and kids know it and they do NOT like it, there is something that GOD put in everyone of us, call it your Conscious or moral compass, ALL of us have one and it says that being Gay is wrong, I have read countless stories of Gay men and woman who know deep down that what they are doing is wrong but they feel trapped and dont know what to do, that being said, kids under Gay parents have a higher rate of depression ( look it up) and are much more likely to be unhappy they may put up a front but its there,I do NOT hate gay people, but I know what it does to society and what it does to familys and is wrong all across the board, defend it all you want its your right but its also MY right to fight it and bet your ass I will... take care.....
David in Houston
Thursday, August 9, 2012 at 6:50 PM
Wait a second. He was 19 years old? He wasn't even raised by gay parents. He was already an adult when he lived with them. So how can he possibly blame them for being a social outcast when they had nothing to do with his upbringing?
As for the Mark Regnerus study. It's already been exposed as a fraud. The study only examined straight parents that had gay affairs. That is quite different than a same-sex couple raising a child, which is what the study claims to be about.
TruthInAction in Telephone, TX
Friday, August 10, 2012 at 7:54 AM
You need to re-read the story. His mother's partner moved in after her kids went to college. He had no male father figure in his home. Thus, he grew up with a lesbian couple as his parents. This is his story and opinion, no less, no more.
Emmanuel in New Orleans, La.
Saturday, August 11, 2012 at 12:50 PM
No, the Regnerus study has definitely not been "exposed as a fraud." While it is true that his operationalization of same sex parents is open to question and criticism, this operationalization was due to the problem of comparing heterosexual married couple families (which have long been institutionalized and recognized) with families with same sex parents (given that most states still do not recognize same sex marriage). You may disagree with Regnerus's methodological strategy. Many competent scholars, such as Darren Sherkat, do. Other major scholars (see the Baylor statement in defense of Regnerus) see it as a useful, if unavoidably problematic, contribution.
demsarerats in Oregon
Saturday, September 1, 2012 at 5:15 PM
David in Houston, you are the fraud, you and other homosexual activists always try to explain away uncomfortable data by claiming that it is biased, and always without facts to back you up. For example, when a study provides data regarding male on male child sexual abuse, homosexual activists always claim that the male abusers of boys were actually heterosexuals. You follow that pattern here, claiming that the homosexuals studied were only having “gay affairs.”
oddball in Texas
Thursday, August 9, 2012 at 8:10 PM
I don't know why the article was edited the way it was, but if read in its entirety two of the previous responders' arguments are cleared up: "Between 1973 and 1990, when my beloved mother passed away, she and her female romantic partner raised me. They had separate houses but spent nearly all their weekends together, with me, in a trailer tucked discreetly in an RV park 50 minutes away from the town where we lived. As the youngest of my mother’s biological children, I was the only child who experienced childhood without my father being around.
After my mother’s partner’s children had left for college, she moved into our house in town. I lived with both of them for the brief time before my mother died at the age of 53. I was 19. In other words, I was the only child who experienced life under “gay parenting” as that term is understood today."
Stuart in Australia
Friday, August 10, 2012 at 12:55 AM
Wow. This guy grew up in a trailer park and had a difficult life. That's unusual;it must've been because of his parents' genders! Kids who grow up in the Bronx always have fantastic, fruitful childhoods!
Mark in Illinois
Friday, August 10, 2012 at 3:38 AM
Geez...this guy may have had a tough life, but he sure is a crappy writer. Maybe he should take some writing courses on how to tell a story accurately. The main issue here is that all gays are not perfect, just like all heterosexuals are not all perfect. And heterosexual kids who grow up in trailer parks have it rough, too. This is about class--which I believe this writer admits in more than one place if you read it closely enough.
If you believe this "patriot" anti-gay crap, you're probably a closet case.
TruthInAction in Telephone, TX
Friday, August 10, 2012 at 8:00 AM
The story and what he said are clear. Perhaps, it is your perspective that causes you to have the need to make such comments?
wjm in Colorado
Friday, August 10, 2012 at 10:11 AM
I don't care what the queers do in private, they can deal with their abberant lifestyle, but they can NEVER procreate. And what they do will NEVER be normal behavior, and as such should NEVER be allowed to raise children. But what else could we expect from the mentally deranged left who embrace evil, and an ideology of Marx that has failed in EVERY instance.
Chutney in Olympia
Friday, August 10, 2012 at 1:49 PM
As a person born into the life of a transgender woman, I find a number of problems with this article. Aside from the obvious atrocious grammar, the writer claims that his youth in a same sex household left him scarred from a lack of male gender roles. Even in a same sex relationship, there is almost always a masculine and a feminine partner. These parings are often times strong enough to demonstrate the proper structure of a family unit.
As has been shown by another post to this article, there has been some suspicious editing that needs to be questioned by the reader. Who changed the article from its original content, and to what end? Throughout my reading, I have noticed that there is an agenda being held forward by the "straight" community of supporting the notion of normalcy for a heterosexual only society. Such a social structure has never existed among the creatures of the natural world and never will.
Once the bias of researchers against findings of homosexual activity among the animal world was removed, same sex acts have been found throughout the animal kingdom. Yet, conservatives still insist that same sex behavior is abnormal, when the facts speak otherwise.
From the point of view of my own life experience, I can say that I experienced more emotional and physical damage at the hands of a father trying to beat some strength to me and thus into being more male, than I would have if I had have been shown acceptance and understanding.
I tried and failed to be straight, as a result, I married and divorced women that did not deserve the pain of the experience. I am thankful that my children are intelligent enough to understand the gravity of my experience and forgive my failure to achieve "maleness" according to my father's model.
Real scientific study has shown that gender is assigned early in fetal development and the environment in which we mature has little impact on our gender identity. http://media01.commpartners.com/AMA/sexualidentityjan_2011/index.html
MNIce in Minnesota
Monday, August 13, 2012 at 12:15 PM
Pseudo "gender roles" in a same-sex partnership are no substitute for the real thing.
Abusive or negligent parenting has terrible consequences. Your history is an unfortunately typical example of that - I've heard enough similar stories to realize it's practically a stereotype of the childhood of a gay person. Your relational difficulties are probably a result of that as much as anything.
The effects of prenatal and childhood exposure to hormone mimics such as bis-phenol A plasticizer are still being studied, but it's known that birth control pill metabolites released into rivers from municipal sewer systems cause serious reproductive disorders in the fish. You may have been poisoned. But in the "natural world," I've never observed homosexual activity among non-human mammals, although I've heard it happens under abnormal conditions.
Problems with the temptations of same-sex attraction are nothing new. The Bible addresses them in several places, such as I Corinthians 6, especially verse 11 (note the past tense of the verb!). In this letter, St. Paul was writing to people in a city infamous for its particularly libertine society, something like San Francisco, but the recipients of the letter had become followers of Jesus Christ. Paul wrote to encourage them to live accordingly, rather than fall again to their own lusts. Rather than trying to follow your earthly father's model, seek first to follow your Heavenly Father. Otherwise, you're trying to bridle the horse's tail instead of its head.
Andy in Raleigh, NC
Tuesday, August 14, 2012 at 1:14 PM
I have 5 close friends or family members that are homosexual men. All of them were abused by male family members. I have talked to 4 of them at length about this, and they confirmed that all homosexual men that they knew had experienced significant abuse during their childhood or early adult years. I know that correlation does not prove causality, but it certainly suggests it strongly enough to be investigated, if APA and others weren't trying so hard to prove that there is nothing to see here...
Abu Nudnik in Toronto
Tuesday, August 14, 2012 at 10:35 PM
What does it mean to be "born into the life of a transgender woman?" That's about as clear as mud. When born, what sex were you?
Regarding the fact that homosexuals play out male and female roles with one dominant and the other submissive, they are indeed roles. They may "demonstrate" the difference, as you say, but they do not embody the difference.
It's a tautology to say that what occurs in nature is natural. But the definition for human nature or even animal nature is far too broad to have meaning. Living beings mostly reproduce through sexual reproduction and that is the norm. A norm is a statistical matter. What is normal is what is more than average and what is abnormal is what deviates from the norm. There is no intention on my part to denigrate that. It is not normal to be a musician but we're glad they exist.
A structural legal and political problem exists when people have to go to government agencies and others to attain the basic things of life. Birth occurs naturally between a man and a woman without the need to consult anyone. To me, this is nature or at least living nature. Until we find the stars have sexes at least.
Best of luck in your voyage. I bear you no ill. My uncle was a flamboyant gay man who was terribly mistreated when trying to visit the lover whose doctors bills he paid. Yet he wasn't able to visit him by mean hospital people. How it would affect the patient should be the only question, not familial affiliation.
Still, I agree with most of the posters regarding same-sex marriage. I'm against it on symbolic grounds. The joining of two sexes, not two people, is the more powerful symbol and symbols float cultures.
Tim in Florida
Sunday, August 12, 2012 at 12:20 PM
It seems every year or so for as far back as I can remember there have been studies clearly indicating that children raised with their mother and father are, on the whole, better adjusted and more successful than those not raised with both parents. Historically this was a clear demonstration that being raised by a single parent offers a lot of difficulties to children as they look for role models, examples of masculine and feminine traits, and understanding where they came from. Regardless of what you want to believe or how good a parent you are, this has been so well established over time it is pretty much irrefutable. Now we bring a new twist to this. Same-gender couples that try to be mother and father. Regardless of how you want to define yourself, the simple fact is you are either male or female by birth. Children are too. You can not say and apple is equal to an orange. I am not saying that any loving person cannot be a good parent figure. There are a lot out there. But let's not get into the weeds and not face the basic truth. Children, to understand their place in the world, and before they are pressured into sexual roles, need to see good examples of men being men and women being women.
Reality Check in Boston, MA
Thursday, August 16, 2012 at 12:47 AM
Oh, I get it. He was the one and only confused teen to have ever existed and it was because his mother was gay. That makes perfect sense to me now. He had straight A's is that also because his mother was gay.
To use one person's anecdote as a representation of anything other than that person's own life makes for a very weak argument.
drew in Texas in Gary, Texas
Saturday, August 18, 2012 at 5:54 PM
I had a 1st cousin who was abused by an older cousin(my brother) and the cousin became a flaming queer. He died of aids 15 years ago. I called him a few weeks before his death and tried to get him to pray the prayer of Salvation, tried to get him to call on the Name of Jesus. He told me it was too late for him. It wasn't and I can only hope he came to that realization before his death
mark in massachusetts
Sunday, August 19, 2012 at 2:58 PM
I wish people would stop bastardizing the word 'gay'. Gay does not mean doing the things that queers do.If the homos don't like being called homo,queer.fairy,etc.then go back in the closet.But, do NOT try to play victim every time you feel that you have been slighted.The biggest hypocrit is that flaming turd Dan Savage.He is not 'gay'. He is an abomination;a disgrace to the human race.I know people named Gay and they hate it when their name is use synonymously with the turd tuckers.