The Right Opinion
Leave Afghanistan Now
Most wars have a turning point that either signals the road to victory or the ditch of defeat. In Vietnam, the 1968 Tet Offensive by communist troops against South Vietnamese and American forces and their allies is regarded as the turning point in that conflict. Though communist forces suffered heavy losses, which would normally define defeat, CBS News anchor Walter Cronkite and others in the U.S. media, portrayed the operation as an allied loss, thus encouraging not only the anti-war movement, but North Vietnamese and Viet Cong troops who believed all they had to do was hang on until America grew tired of the war and quit.
Since the Obama administration appears to care more about not offending those Afghans who want to kill Americans and since it has announced the deadline for the withdrawal of surge-level troops in Afghanistan for later this year, despite the fact that they have stymied the efforts of Taliban insurgents to destabilize the country, maybe it's time to pull all U.S. forces out and leave our puppet, Hamid Karzai, to his fate.
The latest affront comes courtesy of the burning of Korans by U.S. soldiers on a military base near Kabul. Military officials maintain the Korans were being used by imprisoned jihadists to pass messages to other prisoners and were confiscated and destroyed. A spokesman for the NATO-led force said the troops, "...should have known to check with cultural advisers to determine how to dispose of religious material properly." For this unintended action, however, Karzai wants the soldiers to be put on trial and has asked NATO commanders to allow it. If they do, they will have disgraced their uniform.
Does writing in a Koran desecrate it? One might expect it would, but the outrage is over the burning, not the writing. More than 1,700 Americans have died in and around Afghanistan and more than 14,000 have been wounded since the United States invaded shortly after September 11, 2011. And this is the thanks we get? How sharper than a serpent's tooth it is to have a thankless puppet.
When do jihadists apologize for mass murder or religious persecution? Two years ago in Rasht, Iran, Youcef Nadarkhani, a Christian pastor who converted from Islam, was arrested on charges of apostasy. He has been sentenced to hang for his religious conversion. Anyone hear any apologies from "moderate" Muslims about that, much less attempts to shame the ayatollahs, or label them apostates?
The New York Times reported recently that President Obama's three-page apology letter to President Karzai contained these sentences: "I wish to express my deep regret for the reported incident. I extend to you and the Afghan people my sincere apologies." This will only serve as further evidence to our enemies in Afghanistan of America's weakness and lack of resolve in what is likely to be a very long and global war. American impatience, fatigue and a desire not to offend, does not bode well for an American victory or for Afghan liberation. No one worried about offending our enemies during World War II. That's why the forces for good won.
Can Afghanistan be stabilized so as not to pose a threat to America and American interests? Probably not, if the surge forces pull out on schedule and America continues to fight under restrictive and self-imposed rules of war while the enemy does not.
So what's the point? Are we to stay only until after the election so President Obama won't be asked, "Who lost Afghanistan?" If our troops are coming out anyway and if the administration can't define victory, or commit the resources necessary to achieve it, waiting longer only ensures more casualties. As with Vietnam, that is a waste of blood and treasure. Ask the ghosts of the more than 58,000 fallen whose names appear on the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Wall in Washington, or the ghosts of the politicians who are responsible for putting them in their graves.
(c) 2012 TRIBUNE MEDIA SERVICES, INC.

11 Comments
Mike Schuerger Sr.
Thursday, March 1, 2012 at 9:46 AM
Darn it Cal, I don't have time for all of this.That CBS and the other media of the day DID misreport the Tet Offensive (it was a massive military victory for us and utterly destroyed the Viet Cong as a fighting force; after that it was all NVA infiltrators from the North) is true but you are promulgating one of the great lies about Vietnam. HEY LISTEN UP: Vietnam was NOT a defeat. We left with a peace treaty - the Paris Peace Accord 1/27/1973. We left with the South Vietnam forces able to defend themselves ("Vietnamization") based on our promises of supply and promise of support if they were invaded from the North. All American military personnel left Vietnam by April 1973. Our 58,000 dead were from our guys who won and won and won inspite of the handicaps imposed from Washington and left a country able to defend itself! We DID NOT QUIT and WERE NOT DEFEATED!THEN the Democratically-controlled Congress defunded the South Vietnamese. Here's the timeline:June 19, 1973 The U.S. Congress passes the Case-Church Amendment which forbids any further U.S. military involvement in Southeast Asia, effective August 15, 1973. The veto-proof vote is 278-124 in the House and 64-26 in the Senate.Sept., 1973 The U.S. Congress appropriates only $700 million for South Vietnam. This leaves the South Vietnamese Army under-funded and results in a decline of military readiness and morale.Dec 13, 1974 North Vietnam violates the Paris peace treaty.When the North invaded in violation of treaty, the South was down to 20 rounds of ammunition and 2 hand grenades per soldier. A weak President Ford (probably partly due to Watergate) did not send the promised air support.April 30, 1975 Fall of Saigon.But we were out in 1973! The famous evacuation of the US Embassy in Saigon was just that - we evacuated our Embassy.IMO, the Democrats so hated Nixon that they could not stand his "win" in "peace with honor" in getting us out of Vietnam. So they flushed all that blood and treasure and condemned millions to oppression and death.
Greg Welch
Thursday, March 1, 2012 at 9:49 AM
You nailed it again, Cal. Our Armed Forces are forced to go out of their way to not kill and destroy innocent victims. The result of that is: our Armed Forces have paid a terrible price in blood and treasure so a not to offend the religion of Peace. Sen George Aiken Senator from Vermont said it years ago about Vietnam. " Lets declare victory and get the hell out." I truely believe that Pres. Barry Obama could even convince himself that America has won in Afghanistan and announce our withdrawal on a Friday afternoon news dump.
wjmccrindle
Thursday, March 1, 2012 at 10:51 AM
Limited war will never work, never has, never will. You can't keep patrolling the same ground day after day after day. If the troops are not allowed to win, they should not be there. Bring them home and get Islam, the fake religion out of America. Let them know that any attack will result in the TOTAL DESTRUCTION of a city in the country of orrigin, with weapons blessed by swine so that all deceased will rot in their own hell. I can't understand why the leftists are so intent on placating and fawning over the terrorists who would cut off their heads on Jihadi TV. Let them kill each other, and if their jihad spill onto our soil, anihilate with extreme prejudice.
desert
Thursday, March 1, 2012 at 12:06 PM
It is not only GET OUT OF THOSE GOAT ROPING PEST HOLES....but STOP SENDING MONEY TO EVERY PATHETIC DESPOT IN THE WORLD!! Including and especially the "Useless Nerds" commonly known as UN!
Richard Ryan
Thursday, March 1, 2012 at 12:33 PM
I have not always felt the same as Cal, but I finally came to the same conclusion as he. wjmccrindle and desert have put it about as succinctly as anyone possibly could. Get out, and make it plain to all the savages over there that the next attack on the United States will result in Mecca ceasing to exist, immediately.Richard RyanLamar,Missouri - Birthplace of Harry S Truman
CMC (R) Rizor
Thursday, March 1, 2012 at 12:46 PM
one solution proposed for Vietnam was to simply pave it and turn it into a vast parking lot. the same solution would work for any place in the middle east and would require less resources and loss of life. or how about just quit supporting the madness.
M Rick Timms. MD
Thursday, March 1, 2012 at 1:16 PM
The muslims say that they want to be left alone and the reason they are mad at the world is because we are there. Perhaps it really is time to leave these people and their holy books alone, and they can scribble in them all they want. But, the next time they blow up a ship, embassy, hotel, pizza parlor, or high rise building, we should light them up from above.We have tried the civilized humanitarian approach, all the while living in strict adherence to thier customs, and we seem to be rewarded with disdain. There really is nothing over there that we need and can't get elsewhere.I never understood Obama's eagerness to take us out of Iraq, where we had a huge advantage in technology and weaponry based in part on flat terrain, and moved us to the craggy badlands of Afghanistan, with a tactical advantage to the locals -- just ask the Russians or any body else who has tried to fight there.We appear to have made few friends there - time to leave them to the middle ages. See if that makes them happy. Pull our guys out and stop the money.
Howard Reed
Thursday, March 1, 2012 at 2:54 PM
Hello America,What do you expect from a bunch of Satanists being groveled to by Satanists. Let's get serious about winning this war against terrorist Muslims. You want to win this war? Pork is the answer. Strap bombs onto big hogs, drop them over populated cities on days when many people are milling about so they can see them. The big bang, taking out scores who believe they will be immediately blasted down to HELL, tainted by HOG. IT WORKS. It demoralizes and petrifies. Where is the next HOG bomb or bombs coming from and when. That in Allah Land defines numbing, crap in your pants terrorism. First we have to get rid of the Muslim in the White House.The Turban Torpedo
steve
Thursday, March 1, 2012 at 4:58 PM
This sounds almost like a Ron Paul forum with all the GET OUT NOW rhetoric. Obviously, we should have pulled out of Afghanistan as soon as the Taliban was wiped out. We should have chased the remnants into Pakistan, killed all we found and then brought the troops home...around 2002.Afghanistanization, occupation & nation building, has failed just as VietNamization failed and similar efforts in Iraq have failed. The MISSION was and is stupid, which is NOT the fault of the soldiers assigned to it. VietNam was another battle in the long Cold War, a war we eventually won. These endless wars in the middleeast are not related except in stupidity.Only people willing to fight, win and keep their freedom deserve it; the US can't make them want it. If we go to war, the mission must be clear and achievable, rather than pipe dreams and flowery ambiguity.A special forces friend just got back from Iraq in November. The Iraqis he was busy training (western Iraq) are probably already dead or have fled the area.Half the Afghans want the Taliban back, the other half wants to drive the Americans out so they can focus on goatherding, killing rival clans and growing opium. The Iraqis want to get busy killing the rival sects in their country. We should leave them to it.If we must go into Iran (seems inevitable based on the sound of hawk drums), then lets go in, destroy their nuclear facilities and then get the heck out -- in weeks, not years or decades. Our long-term presence in the region is not sensible and it's a waste of blood and treasure.
ScottMacArhur
Thursday, March 1, 2012 at 7:26 PM
This is why I voted for Ron Paul on Tuesday. Funny how all these pundits don't want him, but then after they've assured his loss, they adopt his position.
JLJones
Monday, May 7, 2012 at 7:52 PM
To all of you who think we can win in afganistan? You need to read some history of the region. The last 900 years western powers have tried (just ask the british it's their fourth tour there last 200 years) or the russians (Reagans biggest blunder was helping those people.) I'm just suprised the russians didn't use the cubans to fight this war by proxy which seemed their polocy in the 70's and 80's. We are extremly lucky the losses aren't much heavier for as long as we been there. Bin laden is dead It's time to get our overextended troops home,beacuse we will run out of troops before they run out of patience. Buy the way, the vietnam war might not have happened if Ho-chi-nimh had gotten what he wanted during the PARIS PEACE CONFRENCE OF 1919 HE HAD TO WAIT 54 MORE YEARS.