The Right Opinion
The Pope Strikes a Blow for San Francisco
To find the heart of San Francisco, you need to head south of Market Street, not to the Castro District teeming with people who very publicly define themselves by the perverse acts in which they engage, but to the Mission District.
Here is where the most beautiful of American cities was founded -- not by 49ers, beatniks, hippies or homosexuals, but by devout and dedicated Spanish Franciscans who crossed half the world to bring their faith to a new land.
Mission Dolores is not just the heart of San Francisco, she symbolizes its soul. The Franciscans founded the mission on June 29, 1776, just as American patriots on the other side of the continent were preparing to declare their independence from England with a document that said all men are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights.
Unlike some of the European settlers on the Eastern side of the continent, the priests who founded San Francisco did not bring slaves or try to rationalize human bondage. What they did bring was the best of European civilization -- teaching the indigenous people how to farm and raise livestock and what the priests deeply believed was the one true faith.
Even though these priests named their mission for St. Francis, the church building itself popularly took on the name of Our Lady of Sorrows, which the missionaries had bestowed on a nearby stream.
These pioneers completed the permanent structure of Dolores in 1791. For more than 220 years, what they built has stood strong and intact, the oldest surviving structure in a city where earthquakes and fires and changing fashions have been the ruin of virtually every other venerable thing capable of destruction by man or nature.
Though Mission Dolores itself will surely someday crumble, the truth it represents has not, will not and cannot die.
To those who did not know 20th century San Francisco, the city must have seemed a place in constant cultural flux, where in each passing generation the latest fad in lifestyles briefly took hold and was then swept away.
But under the flotsam and jetsam of the pop cultural trends that moved in and out of the city on decadal tides, the deeper culture of San Francisco remained a solid rock. Like most other American cities of the past century, it was mostly populated by working- and middle-class people dedicated to raising their children to believe in the things that made America great -- hard work, traditional morality, faith in God.
But that underlying bedrock began eroding in the late 1970s, when the homosexual movement arrived in the city.
The truth: Traditional family life cannot survive in a culture seeking to force normalization and moral approbation of homosexual behavior.
The reason: Homosexual behavior is wrong. It violates the natural law. To say two men or two women can marry one another is like saying two plus two is five: It is not the way God made things. To tell people, including children, that they must assent to the government claiming that two men or two women can marry one another is like telling them they must assent to the government telling them two plus two is five.
When a society insists that everyone must assent to the proposition that homosexual behavior is right and good and that everyone must recognize same-sex marriages are right and good, and everyone must assent to the right of same-sex couples to take custody of children who they could never, by nature, conceive, that society has declared war on the natural moral law that the Founding Fathers of this country and the founding fathers of San Francisco correctly understood to be the foundation of true human freedom.
This is not to say homosexuals should not be treated with charity. But their freedom, too, depends on society's fidelity to the truth.
Mission Dolores still stands today, but the church that built her stands forever.
And last week, Pope Benedict XVI sent a new pioneer to that frontier to stand in her defense.
His name is Salvatore J. Cordileone. He is a native Californian and a doctor of canon law, who now serves as bishop of Oakland and chairman of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops Subcommittee on the Defense and Promotion of Marriage. On Oct. 4, he will become the new archbishop of San Francisco.
Cordileone's record shows him to be man of compassion, conviction and courage.
"In places where marriage's core meaning has been altered through legal action, officials are beginning to target for punishment those believers and churches that refuse to adapt," he said in a letter to the Senate Judiciary Committee last November. "Any nonconforming conduct and even expressions of disagreement, based simply on support for marriage as understood since time immemorial, are wrongly being treated as if they harmed society, and somehow constituted a form of evil equal to racism."
Involvement in the marriage issue, he said in a speech in May, led him to see "the erosion of the rights of religious institutions to serve the broader community in accord with their moral principles precisely because of this issue, as well the rights of individuals to have their freedom of conscience respected.
"When I saw what was happening and my eyes were opened," he said, "it made me fear that we could be starting to move in the direction of license and despotism."
The pope has struck a blow for freedom by sending this man to San Francisco.
COPYRIGHT 2012 CREATORS.COM

13 Comments
Sammy in Kansas
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 9:08 AM
All the posturing, rhetoric and political correctness in the world cannot change the fact that God himself says that homosexuality is sin and an abomination in His eyes. I hope we as a people realize this before He decides enough is enough and sends us the way of Sodom and Gomorrah.
wjm in Colorado
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 11:03 AM
They should open a Chick Fil-A at the mission. That would send the sodomites a message.
Jim in Alabama
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 7:14 PM
News flash! Its Wednesday afternoon and I'm hearing reports of Traffic cops being called to handle the over-flow at a number of Chick-fil-A's around the Mobile AL area. A report that their backed up onto the Interstate by the store over in Mobile proper! WooHooooooo!
Kelly B in Vermont
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 11:25 AM
Thank you for spelling out the issues so clearly and respectfully.
Jim in Alabama
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 11:58 AM
As a protestant, believing it a direct relationship with Jesus Christ, with suggested pastoral guidance, as opposed to required intercession, by Priest, by Saint or by Mary the Mother of God, I stand by all my doctrinal differences with the Catholic Church. But the more I learn of love and honor, the more I love and respect the Catholic Church. As the Jews, throughout their history, were visited by God's Prophets, shouting the errors of His Chosen People from the rooftops, so the Historical Church of Christ has been tempted and turned down a thousand side roads, to be woken and shaken again and again to return to the simplest truths of Christ. I pray for the leadership of the Catholic Church to see fully that what so many embraced in the seductive name of "Post-Racialism" and "Social Justice" was, at best, less than advertised. The battle for religious freedom that the Church is now awakening to and waging fervently, inspires and delights me.
Mike McGinn in People's Republic of Maryland
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 1:24 PM
"But the more I learn of love and honor, the more I love and respect the Catholic Church."
May I recommend a fine story told by Tim Staples: "How Jimmy Swaggart Made Me Catholic" (http://shop.catholic.com/product.php?productid=170&cat=16&page=1). You may find that love and respect you mention growing even deeper after you listen to him.
Jim in Alabama
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 3:37 PM
Hmmm...Yup, Ol' Jimmy mighta got ahead of the game going to confession now and then...:)
Jim in Alabama
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 3:45 PM
I suppose this is getting silly, but watching Tom Sellick, playing the NYPD Commissioner on "Blue Bloods", lead his Catholic Family in prayer around the dinner table, is also just something that makes my wife and I incredibly happy. An Oasis in the cultural dessert of Prime Time TV.
sfj in Alabama
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 3:01 PM
"inalienable rights" should be "unalienable rights"
India in Georgia
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 4:24 PM
Great article-- thanks for the fresh perspective on the city of San Fran.
Daryl in Hiwasse
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 9:03 PM
the truth is if you can force every one else to accept that behavior what ever it is it eases ones own conscience from the natural God given standards and values that the spirit recognizes. This does not change the facts regardless, in the end the truth will always come out. I am glad to see the Church standing for that truth in a gentle but effective way. Please notice that every one wants to be "spiritual" but not have a relationship with the true Spirit. The Church as all men have tend to drift from that center. It seems that the Catholic Church is becoming once again centered.
Bernie Morton in Loudon, TN
Wednesday, August 1, 2012 at 9:28 PM
Thank you Mr. Jeffrey for having the courage to speak the truth. As a Protestant are we not Protestant Catholics as compared to Roman Catholics and perhaps we should amplify what we have in common and not dwell on our differences. As a believer in Jesus as the Messiah, I must respect the Roman Catholic Church for two things they have always had correct, according to scripture: 1) homosexuality is an abomination in God's eyes, and 2) the sanctity of life as applied to abortion and euthanasia . Your article was so refreshing and should be on the front page of the New York Times, but I don't think they'll print it. God bless and Shalom in Messiah.
Abu Nudnik in Toronto
Saturday, August 4, 2012 at 1:17 PM
The argument must be opened up to a broader audience. Those who have swallowed the atheistic pill due to excessive materialism need to be shown a couple of things.
1) It's true. The more than 50% who disagree with same-sex marriage are demonized, called evil. This is an absolute 180, a perversion of the nation's morals. Not only that, it is unconscionable despotism to demonize people for thought crimes. 2) What many miss is the symbolic meaning of marriage that existed before the waters were muddied: Marriage is the joining of two sexes, not just two persons. As such, the atomic human race is created and out of their bodies the entire human race, if needs be, could be repopulated.
Cultures live and die on their symbols. This is a very dangerous move. Congratulations to the church but much much more must be done.