The Right Opinion

Food Bunk

By John Stossel · Dec. 5, 2012

With America's “fiscal cliff” approaching, pundits wring their hands over the supposed catastrophe that government spending cuts will bring. A scare newsletter called “Food Poisoning Bulletin” warns that if government reduces food inspections, “food will be less safe … (because) marginal companies … (will) cut corners.”

We're going to die!

Most people believe that without government meat inspection, food would be filthy. We read “The Jungle,” Upton Sinclair's depiction of the meatpacking business, and assume that the FDA and the Food Safety and Inspection Service are all that stand between us and E. coli. Meatpacking conditions were disgusting. Government intervened. Now, we're safe! A happy ending to a story of callous greed.

The scheming lawyers behind the “Food Poisoning Bulletin” argue that without regulation companies will “cut corners.” After all, they say, sanitation costs money, so lack of regulation “creates a competitive disadvantage for companies that want to produce quality products.”

But that's bunk. It's not government that keeps E. coli to a minimum. It's competition. Tyson Foods, Perdue and McDonald's have brands to maintain – and customers to lose. Ask Jack in the Box. It lost millions after a food-poisoning scandal.

Fear of getting a bad reputation makes food producers even more careful than government requires. Since the Eisenhower administration, our stodgy government has paid an army of union inspectors to eyeball chickens in every single processing plant. But bacteria are invisible!

Fortunately, food producers run much more sophisticated tests on their own. One employs 2,000 more safety inspectors than government requires: “To kill pathogens, beef carcasses are treated with rinses and a 185-degree steam vacuum,” an executive told me. She also asked that I not reveal the name of her company – it fears retaliation from regulators.

“Production facilities are checked for sanitation with microbiological testing. If anything is detected … we re-clean the equipment. … Equipment is routinely taken completely apart to be swab-tested.”

None of that is required by government. Government regulation may help a little, but we are safe mostly because of competitive markets. Competition protects us better than politicians.

But people don't trust companies. So it is easy to scare people about food. And the news media know that finding “problems” makes reporters look like crusading journalists. Earlier this year, my old employer, ABC News, “alerted” the public to a new threat, ground beef made with “pink slime.”

It sounds awful! ABC's reporting frightened most school systems so much that they stopped using that form of meat. The food company lost 80 percent of its business.

But the scare is bunk. What ABC calls “pink slime” is just as appetizing as other food.

“Bunk is the polite word,” Dan Gainor of the Media Research Center says. “ABC went on a crusade. Three nights in a row back in March, they pounded on this.”

Well, why shouldn't they, if there's something called “pink slime” in beef?

“Because it's not pink slime. It's ground beef.”

Then how did this all get started?

“A couple activists who used to work for the FDA didn't like this really cool scientific process that separates the beef trimming so you get the remaining ground beef. So they coined this term deliberately to try to hurt this company.”

The company, Beef Products Inc., does something unique. It takes the last bit of trim meat off the bone by heating it slightly. That saves money and arguably helps the environment – not using that meat would waste 5,000 cows a day. In 20 years, there is no record of anybody being hurt by what ABC and its activists call “pink slime” – what the industry just calls “lean beef trimmings” or “finely textured beef.”

“Everybody constantly says, 'You should eat leaner beef.' So when we try to eat the leaner beef, then they take that away from us, too,” Gainor said. “The company … has received awards for how good a job they do for consumer safety. It was just one constant hit job.”

An effective one. After ABC's reports, Beef Products Inc. closed three out of its four plants. Seven hundred workers lost jobs.

Scientifically illiterate, business-hating media will always do scare stories. Don't believe them.

Most of them, anyway.




And restaurant inspections - just a bunch of bunk!! Just another way to freak out patrons over stupid stuff. As you said, competition will keep people honest!

Wednesday, December 5, 2012 at 10:09 AM

Andy in Raleigh, NC replied:

Well, the restaurant inspection scores in IL and NC (the two states I've lived in long enough to have anything to say about this) often have more to do with who does the inspection and who's played nice than who's got the cleanest restaurant... But you just keep believing that your friendly neighborhood paper-pusher can do a better job than you or competition.

Wednesday, December 5, 2012 at 12:04 PM

wjm in Colorado said:

If the reporting is coming from the ministry of propoganda, most likely it is agenda driven lies.

Wednesday, December 5, 2012 at 11:23 AM

Howard Last in Wyoming replied:

I'm from the government, i'm here to help you.

Wednesday, December 5, 2012 at 2:24 PM

Wayne in Hinesville, GA replied:

Howard, Not only is it "I'm here to help you" its also I know better than you what you should eat, wear, drink, drive, etc. In the Socialist agenda, the masses are to stupid to take care of themselves so we have to do it for them. Right down that old road to Communism where the government tells you what school you can go to, what job you can have, and where you can live. Also, we will restrict where you can travel to because you might find out this isn't Utopia after all.

Wednesday, December 5, 2012 at 2:59 PM

Howard Last in Wyoming replied:

Old Sarge, how far can you travel in one of those electric coffins on wheels? Just wait a few years when you will not be able to buy a 3/4 ton pickup.

Wednesday, December 5, 2012 at 3:08 PM

richard ryan in Lamar,Missouri said:

John, this is one of your very best editorials. I guess it`s a wonder I`m still alive. Apparently I`ve been eating "pink slime" for years and it`s a miracle I`m still above ground. I wish there were some way to get the real villans, such as ABC, CBS, NBC,and CNN the hell out of our lives.

Wednesday, December 5, 2012 at 6:47 PM

Robinius in Broomfield, Colorado said:

People don't stop to think that companies have nothing to gain by killing off their customers. Regulators and inspectors, however, have everything to gain - it proves the need for their high paying big benefit jobs. Accidents will happen with or without government inspectors. Somehow humanity survived without the FDA for thousands of years. I wonder how?

Wednesday, December 5, 2012 at 10:03 PM