The Right Opinion
Pedophilia Is the Problem
The bosses of the Boy Scouts of America surprised everyone this week by postponing their decision on whether to allow gay leaders and gay Scouts to join their ranks.
If the BSA's long-standing ban on gays is lifted by national officials in May, the choice to admit gays may be left to local Boy Scout chapters -- as it should be.
Churches and civic groups that sponsor Boy Scout troops wouldn't be forced by the national organization to admit gays. And parents can choose whether they want their child to be in a troop led by a gay man.
If you're asking me if I'd put my child in a Boy Scout troop with a leader who is a known homosexual, I would answer on the side of caution and say "No."
But despite what some of my conservative friends think, allowing gays in the Boy Scouts will not be an open invitation to pedophiles to begin preying on children.
Being gay doesn't mean you are a pedophile. Homosexuality and pedophilia are two completely different issues and studies show that a child is no more at risk of being molested by a gay or bisexual man than a heterosexual one.
As someone who was sexually molested by a camp counselor when I was eight, I know more than I care to about pedophilia and the long-lasting harm it does to children. You can read about my experience and what I learned from it in "Twice Adopted," my 2004 book.
Pedophilia is the most heinous crime against children. But as the newspaper headlines have been telling us for a long time, some of our most famous institutions have a shameful record of coddling the child molesters who work for them.
Everyone knows by now how the men in power at Penn State chose not to tell the police about the serial pedophilia of former football coach Jerry Sandusky because they were afraid to sully the reputation of their "sacred" athletic program. Meanwhile, for years Sandusky was free to prey on new victims.
Penn State's decision to protect its institutional reputation was nothing new. According to HBO's scathing new documentary "Mea Culpa, Mea Maxima Culpa," the Catholic Church -- my church -- has implemented a similar policy whenever pedophiles are discovered in its sanctuaries and schools.
From Wisconsin to Ireland to the Vatican, HBO showed that the church's bishops and cardinals have a long and disgusting history of protecting pedophile priests, ignoring children's allegations of sexual abuse, paying the parents of victims to keep quiet and keeping the sex crimes of priests secret from law enforcement.
In my hometown, we've recently been learning from the Los Angeles Times how for decades the hierarchy of the Los Angeles diocese "plotted to keep law enforcement from learning that children had been molested at the hands of priests."
The BSA's similar method of dealing with child molesters in its ranks also has been exposed by the L.A. Times.
The BSA's own files revealed that between 1970 and 1991 officials chose not to tell police about hundreds of alleged sexual abuses, and in some cases allowed the molesters to continue working or volunteering with the organization.
In one case, the Times reported last fall, a camp director who heard about repeated abuse by a staff member told police he didn't report them because "his bosses wanted to protect the reputation of the Scouts and the accused staff member."
The men who run the Boy Scouts have something in common with the men who run the Catholic Church and Penn State. When it comes to dealing with the sexual abuse of children, they've always chosen to protect their own institutions instead of protecting children.
Pedophilia can be prevented and guarded against, but it's impossible to eliminate. But from now on, when it is discovered, the perpetrators -- who on average molest about 120 victims during their "career" -- should be indicted and punished as criminals.
This should be the case no matter who they are, whether they're straight or gay, or what institution they work for. Our innocent children deserve no less.
Copyright ©2013 Michael Reagan

16 Comments
Fred in Oregon
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 7:48 AM
I have to say this: all pedophiles should be put to death. They never change. I spent many years investigating this scum of the earth. They need to die. This is the only way to keep them from offending again.
Dick in Virgina
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 9:17 AM
It is not a pedophilia problem. Most victims are older than puberty (11-18 range). It, like the Catholic church is a homosexual problem. Young boys are the target, not children in most cases. they are chosen because they are easily intimidated and make convenient targets. Homosexuals are in the BSA just not open. Youth protection policies protect against them. The issue here is not about membership rules or youth protection. It is simply whether or not the practice of homosexuality is contrary to the Scout Oath and Law. Either it is or it isn't. Membership and youth protection simply follow that.
Orf in Pittsburgh
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 10:58 AM
No, no, no, Mr. Reagan! You do not understand homosexuality. Pedophilia is simply a subtype of homosexuality. You do NOT condone homosexuality nationally or locally, not matter how degenerate the folks have become at Sodom and Gomorrah. The Boy Scouts have their oath, which should be as sacrosanct as our Constitution (which is now ignored by the pinheads in Washington, DC).
wjm in Colorado
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 11:14 AM
Homosexual, Pedophile, heck, just all mentally aberrant behavior. There is no room for the psychologically aberrant filth in the Boy Scouts. Allowing that would destroy the institution. I will boycott any business that advocates for this idiocy.
Michael H in Baton Rouge
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 11:26 AM
It's not about being 'gay.' It's about being a sodomite. When you use the correct language, it becomes very clear:
"We at the Boy Scouts of America have again voted to disallow sodomites from joining and leading our organization. We do not agree that this sexual orientation is in keeping with the spiritual mission of our organization which is to develop young men who are physically strong, mentally awake and morally straight. Sodomy conflicts with that mission and for that reason we have deemed it morally inappropriate for the future of our culture."
This is the only answer, and the correct language.
KnoxvilleAJ in Knoxville, TN
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 11:38 AM
@Michael H: Thank you!
Armyofone in Minnesota
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 2:21 PM
I would change the word 'orientation' to 'perversion', but other then that it's fine.
John in NJ
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 11:45 AM
Agree that Sodomite is a better term to use in the discussion. Also, be aware that there are people out there trying to get the Psychiatry association to reclassify Pedophilia as no longer being a disorder. I think their website is B4Uact, or something like that.
Orf in Pittsburgh
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 12:27 PM
Until about 1971 homosexuality was listed as a mental disorder by the American Psychiatric Association. Then the sodomite faction applied the pressure needed to have them remove that diagnosis from their list. Pedophilia will in the not too distant future be accepted by the majority, believe it or not. It will be considered much like the ancient Greeks had practiced their form of "love" between an older man and a young boy. They considered this relationship the highest form of love, a love that is consensual on both sides. Marriage was merely something that needed to be done to produce children. Sicko! The perverts of gender disorientation have the favor of Hollywood miscreants and libtards everywhere. Acceptance of pedophilia will follow sodomite marriages in every state.
HP in Kalispell, MT
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 11:51 AM
Michael H, well said.
Kirk in maryland
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 12:11 PM
My concern is more than just sexual orientation and potential for sexual abuse - that's bad enough. Scout leaders are supposed to be role models. What happens when a gay scout leader introduces his husband? Scouting is supposed to teach values, American, family, Judeo-Christian values. Do gays and their lifestyle represent those values?
BNgranny in MO
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 1:06 PM
What is also being overlooked in this whole thing with the sodomites and Boy Scouts is that these people are trampling all over our First Amendment rights to freedom of association, freedom of assembly, and freedom of speech. BSA is a private organization made up of people with the same values, attitudes and outlooks. The LGBT group is trying to force themselves into a group that absolutely does not share their ideas just as they've done with other organizations. But, so many wanting to be PC (another trampling of 1st Amendment) are not calling them out on this. Let a heterosexual try to join a gay group and all hell breaks loose. Remember the softball teams in WA a year or so ago who rejected team members who weren't "gay enough?" That's a "freedom of association" issue as is this.
The National BSA should say a big, loud "NO" to these people. If they want they can form their own group. Of course, they'd have to leave "morally straight" out of their oath.
Daryl in Bentonville, Ar.
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 1:51 PM
at the very least give them a new island home with no way off, then they can abuse each other to their hearts content....and our children will be safe!!!
Capt. Call in New Mexico
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 5:26 PM
Michael Reagan, I usually agree with you, but this time you are out in left field waiting for a fly-ball when the game being played is basketball! No, it should not be left up to the individual chapters! Don't you see that this is another form of the old, "divide and conquer" tactic? Do you think that this would stop even one lawsuit? No, instead it will multiply lawsuits by the thousands, as the individual homosexuals will begin to complain that the chapters are being unreasonable, that there is no reason why the local chapter should deny them membership, that it is too far to drive to a homosexual chapter, and on and on and on! If the homosexuals want to have a scouting organization, let them build their own from scratch. Homosexuality is ABNORMAL, and SHOULD BE STAMPED OUT.
Jay in FL
Thursday, February 7, 2013 at 9:21 PM
One can't help but observe that our rights to free association and free assembly are being bullied away from us.
mary in Pennsylvlania
Friday, May 24, 2013 at 8:52 AM
I think that all these comments forget that often it isn't just leaders that molest boys .... it just might be the "openly gay (sexually active)" boys scouts who have no sexual boundaries of decency that might be the danger to other boys (teens scouts). That would be my fear as a parent, that my son would be sharing a sleeping tent or rest room with that openly homosexual boy or teen.