Options
Voting With Their Feet
· Tuesday, October 5, 2010
"Californians, here they come -- right back where they ... " Wait a minute, hold on, this ain't the place they mostly "started from" -- Texas, I mean; my home state. But, gosh, are "they" coming, here and elsewhere, to escapes the miseries of unemployment and high taxation in the once-Golden State?
California remains, in many respects, a wonderful state, and I don't have the slightest interest in bashing it. How could a state that nurtured Ronald Reagan not have wondrous, praiseworthy attributes? I recently spent some time there at the Hoover Institution, located at one of my alma maters, Stanford. I can attest to the continuing worth of these noble institutions and to the beauty of their surroundings. I like California, even if more people, reportedly, are leaving it rather than getting there for the first time. My point is a larger one -- a good Leninist point, I might add.
The late -- hardly to be lamented -- Lenin observed during his campaign to enslave Russia that, as respecting where the Russian people wanted to live or not live, they were "voting with their feet." A memorable phrase. People do vote that way. They do it all the time. They register their approval or disapproval of a place, and its living conditions, by staying put or moving along.
A corollary proposition is that the people in charge, unless they happen to be stupid or else as mean and vicious as Lenin, need to notice what's going on. The people in charge don't want to lose a referendum like that. A place gets drained that way -- of talent, resources, initiative, gumption and other indispensable commodities. When the first-rate people move on, a first-rate place becomes second-rate or worse.
California's brains-and-people drain came to notice several years ago. From 1985 to 2000, 111,000 Californians moved to Colorado; another 199,000 sidled over into neighboring Nevada -- though whether the real estate collapse there has propelled some of the new immigrants in new directions, we don't know just yet.
Various websites exist to guide Californians toward acclimation to Texas. One Californian headed our way noted that in Texas, "I can have a five-bedroom, 3,000-square-foot (plus) home with a pool for one-third the price of my 1,350-square-foot home near the freeway." That's assuming, no doubt, he's got a buyer for his home near the freeway. He goes on: "I can put 10-12,000 extra in my pocket each year due to no Texas state income tax." (California's top marginal rate is 9.3 percent.)
The point -- to reiterate -- is that the patience of ordinary people cannot be taken for granted by those who govern them. Hard as it is to get up and move, not least in markets where unemployment is large and home sales are tiny, move is what many do. This kind of truth compels those at the top of a state's pecking order to decide how inhospitable to business they want regulations and taxes to be. A reduction in one or both commodities is a friendly signal: We want people to live here who like to work. We make it easy for them to do so and prosper.
It's sort of the pleasure/pain syndrome. You like pain? Fine. But we haven't got that much of it. What we've got -- in economic terms, and to the extent we can manage it -- is pleasure and delight.
"Never trifle with the marketplace" is an axiom that the present species of American politician needs some help in retaining. The marketplace both purrs and bites back, depending on how it's treated. Example: California. Example: Health insurance companies cutting and leaving markets in which, thanks to ObamaCare, they can't make a profit, such as children's insurance.
The attraction of so-called "Austrian" economics -- which makes a big thing of these marketplace signals -- is much talked of nowadays in analysis of the tea party movement. Why not? The marketplace, when left free enough, tells a free American what he needs to know. You want one more reason why tea party folk desire more freedom from overbearing government? That's it.
COPYRIGHT 2010 CREATORS.COM
Third-party content does not necessarily reflect the opinions of The Patriot Post.
Options
Subscribe
American Spectator Editor in Chief R. Emmett Tyrrell: "The Patriot is an indispensable resource for sound conservative opinion." It's Right. It's Free. Subscribe now!
The Right Opinion
- Peggy Noonan: Mitt Romney's Moment
- Argus Hamilton: From The Comedy Store
- Burt Prelutsky: Time to Start Playing Offense
- Rich Galen: Obama & Romney Tout Good News
- Edwin J. Feulner: 'Law of the Sea' Treaty: Sink It
- Arnold Ahlert: With Democrats, You're Either All In - or All Out
- Oliver North: Memorial Day 2012
- Ken Blackwell: Remarks on Religious Liberty
- L. Brent Bozell: Canada's 'Scientific' Museum of Smut
- Michelle Malkin: Obama's Land of the LOST
- Rebecca Hagelin: The 'Gay Marriage' Spin
- David Limbaugh: Obama and Leahy vs. Sir William Blackstone
Grassroots Commentary
Policy and Analysis
- Heritage Foundation Insider
- Heritage Foundation Research
- American Enterprise Institute
- Center for Strategic and International Studies
- The Cato Institute
- Hoover Institution
- National Rifle Association
- Ludwig von Mises Institute
- Citizens Against Government Waste
- National Center for Policy Analysis
- The Heartland Institute
Our Mission
"The Patriot's mission is to advocate for Essential Liberty, the restoration of constitutional limits on government and the judiciary, and to promote free enterprise, national defense and traditional American values. Our objective is to provide Patriots across our nation with a touchstone of First Principles through brief, informative and entertaining analyses of relevant news, policy and opinion from reputable research, advocacy and media organizations, so they may better support and defend those Principles, and enlist others to join our ranks." —Mark Alexander, Publisher
The Patriot Post is not sustained by any political, special interest or parent organization, and we accept no advertising. Our mission and operations are funded entirely by the voluntary financial support of Patriots like you!
























Pondering Patriot
Some of us in the middle of the country are tired of sending our money to Washington for them to send to the west and east coast. Perhaps succession from the union would help if voting does not. Then let California and New York see if they can scrape up enough money for their big spending ways.
Posted October 5, 2010 at 2:25:06 AM
Bruce R Pierce
I'm one of those that voted with their feet. When I retired from the Military I could have gone back to the "Socialist Republic of California" but decided to stay in Kentucky because. No State Tax on my retirement, much cheeper cost of living as well as lower Taxes on my taxable income. Less laws that intrude on my Liberties. You would think those in Washington D.C. would watch this migration and figure it out and say "wow this could happen at a National level".
Posted October 5, 2010 at 7:49:48 AM
JG
Who is John Galt?
Posted October 5, 2010 at 10:02:13 AM
George
The ability to vote with your feet is by far a more important vote than the one every other year at a ballot box. Too bad that the Progressives took away the greater power of that vote in 1913 with the passage of the 16th Amendment, rendering all but a few of us prisoners of the Federal Income Tax. If all the major taxing power had remained at the state level we would still have a market in governance, giving taxpayers undiminished power.
Posted October 5, 2010 at 11:28:16 AM
Duane
JG
Exactly!!!
Posted October 5, 2010 at 11:39:39 AM
Duane
Support the Fairtax, abolish the IRS and return to freedom.
Posted October 5, 2010 at 11:41:51 AM
Brian
I live in Illinois. People - and jobs - are moving out of state. I would bet it's the same in New York, Massachusetts, Connecticut and other Progressive" states. Have you noticed that there are no Liberals anymore. That label is so tarnished no one wants to claim it. How progressive.
Posted October 5, 2010 at 12:19:03 PM
A.Scott
Answer to Who is John Galt... http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2010/08/finding_john_galt.html
Posted October 5, 2010 at 12:32:57 PM
Hard Thought
Duane: Get Congress to vote for it. They won't because it will cut their throats by making everybody share the load.
JG, I am going as Galt as I can.
When Bill Clinton came in and damaged the military with Don't Ask, Don't Tell, I retired.
Now that Pelosi, Reid and Obama have vitally damaged the economy, I am taking a contracting position overseas. No income tax.
Posted October 5, 2010 at 1:33:36 PM
Warren
The problem I have with all these people voting with their feet, is that after they have trashed a place with their liberal ideas (California), they then move elsewhere and rather than realizing that the reason they moved there is because it's not liberal, they proceed to re-make the new locale into the place they just left. If you come here, leave your liberal ideas and policies at the border of your old state!
Posted October 5, 2010 at 2:28:19 PM
Tulsajudoka
Let's hope that all that's left in these tax and spend states are those feeding off public money...from welfare to illegals to public officials
Posted October 5, 2010 at 2:44:21 PM
Army Officer
Warren,
So true. Vermont has the same problem. It's one of the smallest polities in the nation and "progressives" from places like CT, MA, NJ, downstate NY, etc, didn't like living in the "worker's paradises" their states had become, so they moved to then-conservative Vermont to get some of their freedom back. Too bad they didn't leave their politics at home.
They flooded the place to the extent that liberals overwhelmed the native population in local elections, then eventually state-wide elections too. Now the state that gave us Calvin Coolidge sends Bernie Sanders and Patrick Leahy to the Senate.
Posted October 5, 2010 at 3:18:22 PM
armedandsafe
Duane posted:
Support the Fairtax, abolish the IRS and return to freedom.
Let's put that in the proper sequence, shall we?
#1 - return to freedom.
#2 - abolish the IRS and
#3 - Support the Fairtax,
Posted October 5, 2010 at 3:26:46 PM
Bruce R Pierce
Don't forget get rid of the 17th Amendment.
Give the Staes back the Senate as intended.
Posted October 5, 2010 at 4:59:35 PM
Howard Last
We relocated from the peoples republic of new york state to God's Country, Wyoming. In Great Neck, NY we had a 75 year old house on 1/3 acre and had a property tax of $23,00 (yes 23 thousand). In Wyoming we have ten acres, a brand new house, and oversized attached 3 car garage, deck, patio and hot tub, with a property tax a little over $2,000 (yes less than 1/10th). There is no state income tax vs 8% or so in NYS. Sales tax in NYS apprached 10%. In WY state sales tax is 4% with counties able to add up to an additional 2%, but it requires a vote of the citizens and must be for a definite purpose and definite time period. When was the last time the peasants in NYS voted on a tax? Plus a traffic jam here is 2 cars or trucks and we are located 10 miles from Cheyenne. We are sometimes stopped by cattle drives (there are real cowboys out here). Just turn off the engine and watch. One draw back, we have to sit in the hot tub in the afternoon and watch the sun set over the mountains. I know it is a tough job, but somebody has to do it.
Posted October 5, 2010 at 9:06:19 PM
Tim Mercer
The problem with some of these people who vote with their feet is that when they get to their new homes they continue to vote with their ballots the same way they did in their prior liberal cesspools and support the same kinds of politicians that ruined their previous homes.
If you are going to leave California to come to Texas, leave your liberal democrat ballot in California.
Posted October 6, 2010 at 12:34:15 PM
JG
@Duane and Hard Thought
Should our issue fail come November 2nd...
I'll see you in the valley.
Posted October 6, 2010 at 1:15:22 PM
Peon
Go Fairtax! If the Federal taxes are brought down, the politicians will have to realize that they can't survive without the consent of the taxpayer.
Posted October 6, 2010 at 2:23:21 PM
karl anglin
Anglo-Saxon civilization has taught
the individual to protect his own
rights; Ameican civilization will
teach him to respect the rights of
others.----William Jennings Bryan
(1860-1925)
Posted October 6, 2010 at 7:52:30 PM
Mike the Spike
@ Hard Thought - Just signed for a second year...hate the hours, but love paying no taxes!
@ Duane - FairTax rocks! I HATE taxes, but I can back a program that allows me to pay as much or as little tax as I want.
Posted October 7, 2010 at 4:07:17 AM