Right Opinion

Bench Splinters over Marriage Case

Tony Perkins · Jan. 29, 2015

Alabama’s Ten Commandments judge is issuing one of his own: Thou shalt not trample state law. Unlike most people in his profession, Chief Justice Roy Moore actually seems to understand the limitations of the bench. And undermining the expressed will of the people is one of them.

Last week, when another U.S. District Judge junked 697,591 votes on Alabama’s 2006 marriage amendment, Justice Moore had a word for his colleagues: enough! If the courts are ignoring the Constitution that granted their authority, then Judge Moore will ignore the courts! “Be advised,” he wrote to Alabama Governor Robert Bentley (R), “that I stand with you to stop judicial tyranny and any unlawful opinions issued without constitutional authority… As you know, nothing in the United States Constitution grants the federal government the authority to redefine the institution of marriage.”

In a refreshing show of defiance, Moore left no doubt where he stood on the issue. “As Chief Justice of the Alabama Supreme Court,” he insisted, “I will continue to recognize the Alabama Constitution and the will of the people overwhelmingly expressed in the Sanctity of Marriage Amendment.”

For Roy Moore, being labeled a judicial maverick is nothing new. The long-time Alabama justice lost his seat (only to be reelected to it by voters) for refusing to tear down the courthouse’s Ten Commandments monument. Now he’s asking his Governor not to tear down 81% of the state, who exercised their constitutional right to preserve the definition of marriage – and an endless slate of other issues under their authority.

Fortunately, Gov. Bentley seems to recognize the threat of these unelected judges – not just to marriage, but to self-governance. “The people of Alabama voted in a constitutional amendment to define marriage as being between man and woman. As Governor, I must uphold the Constitution.” While the Left mocks Moore as some sort of judicial outlier, the reality is, this is how federalism is supposed to work. States are not, and the founders never intended them to be, the federal courts’ lap dog meant to do the lawless bidding of activist judges. At what point did the opinion of a handful of judges start mattering more than the people’s? What happened to self-determination and self-governance?

If we continue to let unelected judges dictate our policy and elevate their own views above voters’, then marriage is just Chapter 1 of the playbook to fundamentally remake society. Libertarians and anyone else foolish enough to think the courts will suddenly embrace their limits after the marriage debate are in for a big surprise. Instead, the courts will start flexing their growing muscle over other laws they were never intended to rewrite – like the First and Second Amendments.

Fortunately for Alabamans (and Americans), Roy Moore is in the judiciary but not of it. Like the great man once imprisoned down the road in Birmingham, the Chief Justice understands, “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere. We are caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied in a single garment of destiny… We know through painful experience that freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor; it must be demanded by the oppressed.” For more on Justice Moore’s stand, check out his interview on [yesterday’s] radio show!

Fed up with the Fed!

There’s a new “hate group” in town: the American people! According to a new poll, voters are more disgusted by the federal government than ever – shocking… no one. Scandals and corruption are almost synonymous with the Obama administration, thanks to deception and fraud of the IRS, Veterans Administration, Health and Human Services, and every other agency racing to out-disgrace the last.

The Treasury Department is leading the hall of shame, with just a 57% score with 1,772 people. (That’s 18 points lower than the average industry!) Based on the American Customer Satisfaction Index, people were mostly frustrated by the government’s service “specifically how courteous, helpful, and professional” each department’s staff is. “Plus, Americans say that the services the government provides aren’t always easy to navigate or delivered in a timely manner,” more so than years past. (Thanks, ObamaCare!)

Although every agency scored below the national average (75%), the Defense Department was closest to hitting the mark at 73%. Inefficiency has always been the government’s middle name, but sheer incompetence and distrust are close seconds. Unfortunately for Americans, they can’t exactly shop around for a better government. And unlike other “customers,” their dollars are committed whether they get a quality return or not.

But here’s the silver lining. The public’s loathing of government presents a great opportunity for the new Republican majority in Congress – if they bring the long overdue accountability to these agencies they promise.

The ABCs of Dan Savage…

Dan Savage says “it gets better,” but don’t be surprised if viewers get bitter after ABC’s newest program. The Disney-owned network, for years a shill for the LGBT agenda, is taking their activism to amazing lows with its plans to bring the controversial “sex therapist” to life in a regular feature. His dark and vile attacks on Christians have been well chronicled by Savage himself (so vulgar most are unprintable).

Lately, though, the open atheist homosexual has taken a break from harassing high schoolers and Republicans to focus on this new fall sitcom, which, producers say, “will follow the younger years of Savage’s life and the experiences of his family following his decision to come out of the closet.” As desperate as the networks are to out-shock the competition, does ABC really want a pilot show based on an anti-Christian bully like Dan Savage? And will they be using this footage?


This is a publication of the Family Research Council. Mr. Perkins is president of FRC.

Don't miss Tony Perkins and other great columnists. Subscribe today!

Click here to show comments

Coronavirus got you homebound?
Stay current with America’s News Digest.