Trump Should Put Away His Pen and Phone
All of a sudden, we’re all originalists and believers in the sagacity and inviolate handiwork of long-ago white males.
President Donald Trump’s trial balloon about changing birthright citizenship via executive order has brought a hail of denunciations. He wants, the critics say, to change the Constitution under his own power, in the service of the allegedly racist goal of excluding the children of illegal immigrants from U.S. citizenship.
Contrary to the chest-beating, there’s a serious case that the 14th Amendment, which grants citizenship to anyone born here who is “subject to the jurisdiction” of the United States, is ambiguous on whether the provision applies to illegal immigrants. And, as a policy, nearly unlimited birthright citizenship has obvious downsides. But the executive order the president is contemplating is a bad idea and should go in whatever circular filing cabinet is reserved for misbegotten inspirations that he’s eventually talked out of.
The argument about the 14th Amendment is whether it, with the exception of diplomats and foreign armies, is meant to give citizenship to the children of anyone here, or whether it requires some deeper allegiance to the United States. The case for the latter, more limited interpretation has some formidable advocates, but the expansive view has more supporters and also long-standing practice on its side.
It’d certainly be instructive to have the Supreme Court weigh in, since the question of illegal immigrants hasn’t been directly addressed by the courts, and no one who debated and adopted the 14th Amendment contemplated a large-scale influx of undocumented immigrants, or the rise of birth tourism.
Illegal immigrants, of course, come here in open defiance of our laws and stay by continually violating our laws. They are subject to our jurisdiction, but do everything they can to evade it, and aren’t fully subject to it — it wouldn’t make any sense, for instance, to try an illegal immigrant for treason. As a policy matter, it is perverse that illegal immigrants win one of the world’s great lotteries through their lawbreaking, by getting citizenship for their children.
So it’s understandable that Trump opposes the status quo, and is frustrated by it. But that doesn’t mean he should issue an executive order.
Despite the cottage industry of analysis of him as a budding Hitler, Trump has so far avoided the unilateral excesses of President Barack Obama. By and large, his executive orders and regulations have been devoted to reversing Obama’s. It’s been a tit-for-tat unilateralism. A birthright order would be different.
Congress has legislated in this area and codified the language of the 14th Amendment. It hasn’t acted to change the interpretation of birthright citizenship, even though it had ample opportunity to do so across the decades. (An effort spearheaded by Harry Reid in the 1990s never went anywhere.)
So if Trump wants to test the limits of birthright citizenship, he really needs Congress to move, which it won’t. Desperation to change the rules on immigration even though Congress wouldn’t act is what made Obama rewrite the immigration laws on his own. Trump should resist the same temptation.
Regardless, if the president goes down this route, he will likely get swamped in the courts. There would be an immediate injunction. A case might not even make it to the Supreme Court, and the courts wouldn’t even have to speak to the underlying issue of birthright citizenship — they could just rule that the executive order exceeds the president’s authority. Even such a limited decision would be widely interpreted as an affirmation of the current interpretation of the 14th Amendment.
The best way to combat illegal immigration is an E-Verify system that requires employers to ascertain whether their employees are legal. It doesn’t have the emotive power of Trump’s other immigration priorities — the wall, tent cities and troops at the border, and now this — but it is more achievable and would be more effective.
Meanwhile, he should put his pen and phone away.
© 2018 by King Features Syndicate