Madison: The Shape of Things to Come

· Monday, February 21, 2011

Last May we saw violent political riots in Greece and last week a February of discontent began in Madison, Wisconsin. While the issues at the heart of the Wisconsin protest aren't exactly identical to the austerity measures dictated to the Greek government as a condition of accepting a continent-wide financial bailout, they're still all about spending money the government doesn't have.

The Madison protest arose from a GOP bill which would both curtail the negotiable items in labor contracts and bring to heel the ability of public sector unions to continually collect dues by removing "closed shop" provisions for certain employees and mandating annual authorization elections -- those provisions strike (no pun intended) at the heart of the Big Labor political machine. To stall the inevitable passage Democrats in the Wisconsin Senate took advantage of a rules loophole and left the state, leaving their Republican counterparts fuming but powerless to take action on the law. Considering these Democrats have been offered sanctuary by religious leaders in adjacent states, they could be gone awhile.

(It shows that elections mean things -- had one more Republican been elected last fall to the Wisconsin Senate the GOP would have had the twenty Senators they need for a quorum and passed the bill over sure Democratic opposition.)

Needless to say, life in the Badger State has been turned upside down by these protests, which have resulted in a near-continuous occupation of the state capitol building by noisy union-backed mobs. In particular, those who send their kids to the public schools which shut down for most of last week as teachers called in "sick" to join the protest are upset at the changes in plans they had to make. Spending precious vacation days cooped up at home with the kids because school is shut down tends to promote a sour attitude in parents.

Over the next few weeks the unrest shows signs of spreading to Columbus, Indianapolis, and Nashville as those states also employ tactics to starve the union beast and bring future deficit spending on employee benefits and pensions under control. With the exception of Indiana, all of these states feature newly-installed Republican governors and state legislators with TEA Party-influenced conservatives. They see the bloated state payrolls and generous union contracts as target number one of a necessary austerity program to keep state budgets in balance.

Yet the unions are primed for a fight and they are getting assistance from the nation's capital. Organizing For America -- the front group originally conceived as part of the Obama campaign and now part of the Democratic National Committee -- has people on the ground as part of the union protest. Their shrill tweets talk about student walkouts and beg lawmakers to "preserve the collective bargaining rights of (Wisconsin's) public workers." OFA spouts a lie in this case: Even under the proposed law workers will still have the right to organize; only the scope of negotiable items changes.

Leftists also see this protest as their answer to the TEA Party, and admittedly thus far it's seen more success than the Coffee Party movement or Comedy Central's Rally to Restore Sanity. Neither did much to deflect the electoral pounding that led to the precarious position Democrats and their union allies in Wisconsin and nationwide now stand upon.

But the track record of the GOP taking on the unions and government spending is mixed. In this latest confrontation Big Labor is again counting on Republicans and newly-elected Governor Scott Walker to blink first, just like the Gingrich-led Republicans in Congress did after the 1995 government shutdown. In fact, the events in Wisconsin could be seen as a state-level rehearsal for the prospect of a federal government shutdown once our borrowing limit is reached next month. You can be sure the Democrats and unions have a plan for that eventuality as well.

Walker and Wisconsin Republicans have drawn a line in the sand as their state faces a massive budget deficit. Perhaps they may relent somewhat on the rules about limiting the influence of the unions by keeping the public sector a "closed shop" and tinker with the percentages workers need to contribute to their health insurance and pensions, but the state which was the first to legalize public sector unions back in 1959 may be the most successful in taking them on if they can somehow pass this bill. Like California and other states have shown, allowing unions free rein during good times and bad has placed state finances at the point of no return.

If there were a time to break the back of the public sector unions once and for all, this may be it. Workers should be free to organize for collective bargaining, but the current system is unsustainable and only enriches the union leadership and a party long out of touch with the American people it claims to represent.

Stand strong, Governor Walker.

Writing from Maryland's Eastern Shore, Michael Swartz is a freelance writer and blogger whose home site is monoblogue. He has written for, among others, Pajamas Media, Examiner.com, and Liberty Features Syndicate. Contact him at lfs.mswartz@gmail.com.


Third-party content does not necessarily reflect the opinions of The Patriot Post.


Comments

Hard Public Worker

You poor, poor clueless being. Walker isn't being a Gov right now. He's being a teenager who's motto is "My way or the highway." What about the tens of thousands of people protesting? Wisconsin is doing EXACTLY what it's suppose to do in cases like this. We are peacefully assembling, in hopes that a crucial discussions will take place. Part of Walker's job is to listen to ALL of Wisconsin. He's not even considering anything outside of his ideas. That is not a mature way to be a leader. And the few days that Madison didn't have school? I hate to tell you, but if this bill goes through it will be alot worse. Who's going to be able to be a teacher? Who's going to afford to be able to work in a day care center? These parents whine about the days they've had to take care of their kids... but guess what. The people that are being treated so badly by Walker are the people that take care of your children and your families.

Posted February 21, 2011 at 1:59:22 PM


Michael Swartz

Clueless? I don't think so.

So the Wisconsin Senate Democrats, by leaving the state, are doing "EXACTLY what it's suppose (sic) to do" - is that your contention? I'd also be curious to know just how many of those thousands actually live/work in the state and how many were bussed in to create trouble.

It seems to me that Governor Walker is doing what he needs to do to keep his budget in balance, as prescribed by law. In a republic, one can hear as many or as few ideas as they wish but they are still beholden to the law and the people they represent - Walker and his philosophy was installed by the majority of voters, who also gave him a Senate controlled by Republicans.

By the way, the SEIU is trying to pull this same stunt in a number of other states (including here in Maryland.) It seems to me that it's your side trying to nationalize what, at heart, is a state issue - so is that what the Wisconsin Democrats are supposed to do?

If a teacher or a day care worker cannot take a little bit less in their take-home pay in paying for their health insurance and retirement pension (the vast majorities of which are still being picked up by Wisconsin taxpayers) perhaps for the next vote on union representation they could say no and get back the union dues to help make up the difference.

We know what this struggle is really all about. The unions don't care nearly as much about the workers as they do about losing the dues check-off. Follow the money.

Posted February 21, 2011 at 6:44:01 PM


Elizabeth

I cannot believe I read this. I comb the Internet for inspiration regarding how to push back, if possible, at my college president similarly rabid and reactionary, looking for ways to break labor's back in New York State, and I look to Wisconsin--bastion of Progressivism for pete's sake--and find such roll-over types as YOU, stabbing in the back Wisconsin's laudable history protecting workers' rights. . .

For SHAME. If YOU feel "guilty" about all YOU have gained, on the backs of others braver than you, more willing to go to the mat to push for Democracy. . . then by all means, give up YOUR pension, and health care. Do it.

But please--otherwise, shut the heck up, and let people with actual concern for our nation's future look to its younger citizens' RIGHTS.

Posted February 21, 2011 at 7:20:44 PM


Jona Toblesman

"Hard Public Worker"

Your preamble is an oxymoron.

Posted February 23, 2011 at 9:45:27 AM


Michael Swartz

Oh Elizabeth, if you only knew...

Let's just say I used to have those things you said I should give up until the prospect of a "progressive" President and policies enacted by his party helped to take away those things (which, by the way, were NOT taxpayer funded like Wisconsin's public-sector workers are.)

So - and I'll ask politely - don't tell me to shut up about our nation's future. I have a daughter a little older than you and you better believe I'm damn concerned about the nation she'll inherit.

Posted February 23, 2011 at 4:24:48 PM


Call Me Mom

Of those protesters who are actually citizens of WI, the majority are most likely from Madison itself. As a native of WI, whose hometown is Madison, I can tell you that Madison is not reflective of the rest of the state.

Someone once described Madison as "30 square miles surrounded by reality". They were right.

This bill is doing nothing more than giving the taxpayers a place at the bargaining table in WI.There are more cuts to come.

Posted February 24, 2011 at 5:27:20 PM


Call Me Mom

Cont.

I wish the out of state hooligans would go home, the rest of the states would mind their own business, our AWOL Senators would do their jobs, and that the idea that parents having to spend time with their children wasn't being presented as a punishment of some sort. These are our children. I won't speak for anyone else, but I loved spending time with mine. Homeschooling is the way to go.

Those from out of state calling for violence should be ashamed of themselves. This is Wisconsin, not Egypt. We are better than that.

As for union busting rhetoric, unions are simply a means to an end, better working conditions and pay -at least they were supposed to be. Now many of them are abusing the authority and funds granted to them by their members. Members who should realize that they are citizens first.

Bankrupting the state will not help these people, and if they were remembering to be citizens first, they would know that. These continuing demonstrations are serving only to deepen the resentment the private sector employed citizens already have for public sector unions.

Nobody is winning as long as they continue.

Posted February 24, 2011 at 5:36:35 PM


D

We are going to crush the corporate owned opposition. The rights of the working class are not for sale. American working class citizens have watched corporations buy political influence for far too long and have not stood up for themselves for even longer. This is what democracy is about; not high paid lobbyists working for corporations but working class people standing up for themselves and refusing to believe that corporations are more powerful than the will of the people. It has begun. America is taking back its government from corporate owned politicians

Posted February 26, 2011 at 9:28:20 PM


Post a Comment

Please keep comments civil and brief. Obscene, profane, abusive and off-topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked.

(required, displayed)
(required, not displayed)
Facebook Twitter YouTube RSS Connect with The Patriot Post






Our Mission

To Support and Defend -- Read The Patriot Post -- It's Right. It's Free. -- www.patriotpost.us

"The Patriot's mission is to advocate for Essential Liberty, the restoration of constitutional limits on government and the judiciary, and to promote free enterprise, national defense and traditional American values. Our objective is to provide Patriots across our nation with a touchstone of First Principles through brief, informative and entertaining analyses of relevant news, policy and opinion from reputable research, advocacy and media organizations, so they may better support and defend those Principles, and enlist others to join our ranks." —Mark Alexander, Publisher


The Patriot Post is not sustained by any political, special interest or parent organization, and we accept no advertising. Our mission and operations are funded entirely by the voluntary financial support of Patriots like you!

Support The 2012 Patriot Fund