The Right Opinion
The Upside of the Downside
One of my heroes, Irving Kristol, used to say that there's nothing wrong with the country a bad recession couldn't fix.
Kristol (father of the more famous Bill, by the way) wasn't hoping for a recession, he was merely making the point that so many of the problems with our culture, both popular and political, were the sorts of challenges that come with affluence.
Wealth makes it easier to abandon the old customs, rituals and habits of the heart that generated the wealth in the first place.
For instance, I always love reading about irresolute rich families that lose their mojo within a generation or two. When the illiterate shipping and railroad magnate Cornelius Vanderbilt died, he had amassed a personal fortune larger than the U.S. Treasury. Within a few generations, his family had squandered it all. Vastly better educated and more refined than their tobacco-juice-spitting patriarch, they also lacked his entrepreneurial drive and financial thrift because they never needed it. It's a pattern that repeats itself in countless families. Billionaires so often raise their children to be playboys or poets.
Edward Gibbon's theory of the fall of the Roman Empire has come in for some revision over the years, but his basic thesis still has merit. The Romans became so wealthy they lost the civic and martial virtues that built the empire in the first place. They in effect contracted out the hard work of civilization that allows civilization to continue.
And then, of course, there's the universally recognized lesson of Rocky Balboa, who learned the hard way from Clubber Lang (aka Mr. T) that success can make you lose the eye of the tiger more than failure can.
Anyway, you get the point.
And while I hope we can get back to having the problems of a rich country really soon, it's worth pausing to appreciate America's capacity for self-correction and the fact that many of the problems we had over the last couple decades were good problems to have.
Illegal immigration is a great example of a rich country's problem. (For instance, no one but terrorists are sneaking into Somalia in search of work.) After years of screaming over what to do about it, the rate of illegal immigration has suddenly plummeted. Some say it has actually stopped entirely, as many illegal immigrants have started going home. Yes, there are other issues at work, but no one denies that if the U.S. economy were in good shape, we wouldn't be seeing what we're seeing.
In terms of self-correction, the examples are all over the place. In 2005, America had the lowest personal savings rate since 1933. In fact it was outright negative -- i.e., consumers spent more money than they made. Today it's at 3.4 percent.
For years intellectuals looked enviously at the way the Japanese live in multigenerational homes. Grandma and grandpa looked after the grandkids, and everyone looked after grandma and grandpa. From 2008 to 2010, American multigenerational households increased at a faster rate of growth than in the previous eight years combined, according to AARP.
In perhaps the most welcome news, laser tattoo removals have increased by 32 percent from 2011 to 2012 alone. "Employment reasons" are cited as the new No. 1 reason for the procedure. It turns out that in an era of austerity, having a Chinese-character tattoo that translates into "I have Kung Pao chicken pants" is an act of unnecessary self-indulgence rather than glorious self-expression.
It also turns out that our politics have a capacity for self-correction that few experts anticipated. When President Obama came into office, his administration's mantra was "a crisis is a terrible thing to waste." This little prayer to cynicism masquerading as an idealistic insight was used to justify vast expansions of government. The social scientists even told us this was to be expected. After all, they explained, during times of economic hardship, voters rally around the government.
Except that's not true. Yes, it happened during the Great Depression. But ever since, liberalism has been a luxury thriving on prosperity, not austerity. The Great Society was a byproduct of the so-called Affluent Society.
Instead of a tsunami of political support for ObamaCare and government unions, we got the Tea Party and the rollback of public-sector collective bargaining. Instead of massive support for Obama's green agenda, the air is thick with calls for more drilling, more fracking and more Keystone pipelines. It turns out the "new progressive era" was just too pricey.
Hopefully, the interminable winter of Obama's "Summer of Recovery" will soon end. And when it does, I hope we take the lessons to heart.
(C) 2012 Tribune Media Services, Inc.

9 Comments
Robert Risko in Michigan
Wednesday, June 6, 2012 at 7:10 AM
Mr. Goldberg shares a timely truth about our current times. Here he has captured examples that should make us courageous, bold and even optimistic about the U.S. Constitutional limitations that are being so valiantly fought for today and the benefits of an economic downturn.
A liberal friend of mine told me that if I could figure out how to instill personal responsibility into the culture even he would vote for me. I think Mr. Goldberg has presented at least one step toward teaching this essential character trait through hardship.
Hard Thought in Vicenza, Italy
Wednesday, June 6, 2012 at 7:18 AM
So, if we leave the Democrats in charge for four more years, all of the illegals will go home? That's too high of a price to pay!
Nobody sane is against immigration. It is the illegal immigration that harms our country.
The line about the Chinese ideogram tattoo was hilarious!
p3orion in Deepindaharta, Texas
Wednesday, June 6, 2012 at 12:24 PM
B.S. is one of the most expensive commodities out there, and one that defies the supply-demand equation: the more there is of it, the more it costs.
Nevertheless, in good times, we can afford it, and the American people are willing to buy just about all the Left can produce. But in lean days, it becomes apparent (to most intelligent people) just how much B.S. costs.
Holmes Simons in Tampa
Wednesday, June 6, 2012 at 1:11 PM
Mr. Goldberg, why do you refuse to admit to yourself that Barack Hussein Obama, aka Goober, has and continues to act "to transform America" into a communist/socialist/Marxist state, that he has never done anything in the best interest of America and its citizens, and that he is a fraud with deep radical beliefs, a liar, and a treasonous criminal? You are not alone in the world of pundits who continue to try to paint this man as something other than who and what he really is. Do you read anything other than your own stuff and liberal propaganda?
I was long ago convinced that those who perceive themselves to be the journalist voices of conservatism are just a farce. How does it feel to live your life and build a career as a farce? It must be gratifying, because you refuse to face the truth. Or, maybe, you are like Maureen Dowd who is now eating alive those whom she has been licking for the past four years. So, what is it, man, are you a farce, a moron, a hypocrite, or a journalist reporting the truth. Your future articles will tell the tale.
Joe in Texas
Wednesday, June 6, 2012 at 4:25 PM
Seriously, what is wrong with you? You didn't comment on ONE thing that you didn't like in this piece. Just a generic complaint about what you're unhappy about.
Write your own if you want to dictate what all these OPINIONSITS should write about. They all have different minds. His PAST articles have already told who he is. Do some research!
Holmes Simons in Tampa
Wednesday, June 6, 2012 at 5:15 PM
Read my comments to his past articles.
p3orion in Deepindaharta, Texas
Thursday, June 7, 2012 at 4:17 PM
Cool your jets, Holmes.
I fail to see where Mr. Goldberg, in this or any of his articles, has ever tried "to paint [obama] as something other than who and what he really is." In fact, in this particular column which seems to have so thoroughly set you off, he only obliquely even refers to BHO, but is talking more about the lasting effect the obama administration has had on our nation and how it views itself.
I myself predicted four years ago that in the long run, an obama presidency might be better for America than four years of John McCain RINO policies, which would have only taken us slowly where obama has taken us quickly. As with some of George W. Bush's more ill-advised policies ("No Child Left Behind," the prescription drug benefit entitlement, steel tariffs) not only would the Republicans in Congress have felt more inclined to go along with a president of their own party, but any action McCain might have taken would have nonetheless been labelled "conservatism" by the media, thereby tainting the "brand name" of actual conservatism for years to come.
I confess that I was unprepared for just how radically and damagingly Socialist obama would turn out to be, but I still contend (as does apparently Mr. Goldberg) that his dreadful presidency has, if nothing else, served as a long-needed wake-up call, as evidenced by the rise of the TEA Party movement, the primary defeat of RINOs like Dick Lugar, and a new appreciation of the Constitution in this nation.
Holmes Simons in Tampa
Thursday, June 7, 2012 at 10:06 PM
@p3: I believe that Obama has always had an ulterior motive that is so contrary to the Amercian Spirit of which I am familiar that even when he blatantly rubs our face in it no one comprehends what he meant when he proclaimed that he was going "to transform America." He is accomplishing that by illegal, criminal, traitorous, unconstitutional acts and a plethora of regulatory changes, which, if unchecked, will force America away from a Constitutional foundation to a Marxist society. I do not believe that Jonah Goldberg or other self-proclaimed pundits perceive this reality, and, accordingly, they tend to interpret events from an incorrect perspective, delusion. I am, therefore, intentionally harsh in my remarks in the attempt to blast them into recognition of a political movement with an anti-American focus. Nudging is not a style I like to employ.
Jim in Alabama
Wednesday, June 6, 2012 at 10:13 PM
Holmesy , This article has some great insight as to the ebb and flow of things. Your outcry sounds just like you didn't sleep well, burnt your toast, and spilled your morning coffee on your way to a job you hate. Lots of folks know exactly what Obama is. It's not that well hidden a secret. And, by the same token that Obama would act every bit the Tyrant as his hero, Mao Tse-Tung, IF he could get away with it, IF America were truly ripe for Revolution, there is no place, nor yet a need, for organized Militia's to stop his coup d'etat. You gotta see that the John Birch Society had it damn well right yet did more for the cause of Socialism than any half dozen banana republic dictators. Wisdom is to concentrate on victory and effective persuasion. Its foolish to rant in a way to inflame and feed and justify the Propagandists of the left. Obama is all that you say. But he also a flake and he is about to take a magnificent fall. Wisconsin was nothing, November will be glorious. This article tells the story of that approaching wonder very well.