The Right Opinion

Hey, Fat Cat Unions: Pay Your 'Fair Share'

By Michelle Malkin · Dec. 7, 2012

Message for wealth-bashing millionaire actor Ed Asner: Man up and take responsibility for lying to America's schoolchildren.

Confronted by a producer for Fox News Channel's “The Sean Hannity Show” this week, the left-wing celebrity claimed he couldn't remember “a thing (he) said” on a vile propaganda video produced and published by the California Federation of Teachers. Asner narrated the unforgettable eight-minute anti-capitalist screed geared toward children.

Think Occupy Wall Street meets Sesame Street. “Things go downhill in a happy and prosperous land after the rich decide they don't want to pay taxes anymore,” Asner warbles in a folksy grandpa voice. After education reform journalist Kyle Olson of blew the whistle on the film's vulgar cartoon depiction of a “rich” man urinating on the “poor,” the teachers union whitewashed the animated images from the video.

While the Occupy-cheerleading teachers have to concoct such fantasy scenes, informed Americans remember that it was the Occupiers themselves who openly defecated in the streets. What's even more grossly comical is the sight of pampered Asner shilling for the “progressive” war on prosperity while ignoring Big Labor's own self-serving evasion of their “fair share” in taxes.

The California Federation of Teachers, an AFL-CIO affiliate that rakes in an estimated $22 million in coerced dues, enjoys nonprofit, tax-exempt 501©(5) status. So does CFT's larger counterpart, the California Teachers Association, which collects a whopping $300 million in annual dues. While they burn through mountains of dues lobbying for everyone else to pay higher taxes, these Democratic partisan heavies pay nothing in either federal or state income taxes. Zero, zip, nada. In theory, the unions are entitled to this special status because their “primary” purpose is to “secure better working conditions, wages and similar benefits” for their members.

In practice, of course, the unions are Democratic Party front groups that shovel hundreds of millions of dollars to liberal causes and candidates – against the will of their rank-and-file members and often without their knowledge.

Mark Levin's ever-vigilant Landmark Legal Foundation has pressured the Internal Revenue Service for more than a decade to force national teachers unions to file proper federal reporting and IRS statements regarding their hidden political expenditures. (The overwhelmingly Democratic donations are not tax-exempt.) As a result of Landmark's investigative work, the Wisconsin Education Association admitted in 2006 that it had failed to pay more than $171,000 in federal taxes on Democratic political expenditures.

Given the immense difficulty that dissenting teachers across the country have had in challenging the abuse of their dues for political purposes, it's clear this is the tip of Big Labor's tax-evasion iceberg.

In addition, the national parent organizations of the CFT and CTA also benefit from widespread property tax exemptions on their ownership of lavish real estate used for union brass vacations and retreats. Fox Business Network reporter Elizabeth MacDonald's investigation of IRS records earlier this year shed light on several tax-sheltered, union-owned luxury hotels, golf courses and country clubs – including the “swanky” AFL-CIO-owned Westin Diplomat resort in Florida and the UAW's $33 million lakeside resort and golf club in Onaway, Mich.

“What the documents don't show,” FBN noted, “is whether union members like teachers, firemen and cops get invited to these junkets – or even approve of or know about the use of their dues to outright buy and run resorts, or spend on junkets, among other things.”

Then there's the Obamacare Cadillac tax exemption for unions. Delivered behind closed doors and out of sight of C-SPAN cameras, the Obama White House cut a lucrative sweetheart deal with AFL-CIO, Service Employees International Union and other labor groups to shield them from the federal health care mandate's steep 40 percent excise tax on high-cost health care plans. The 90 percent of Americans who don't belong to unions and participate in these plans must pay their “fair share” beginning in 2013.

But Big Labor's cozy Cadillac tax escape clause is effective until 2018. Even after that deadline, union dental and vision plans will remain exempt. The cost? $60 billion in foregone tax revenue.

Who are the greedy, selfish, filthy-rich tax evaders pissing on the poor and politically unconnected now?



Tod the tool guy in brooklyn ny said:

JFK was the last of thr real Democrats, along with Zell Miller, of course.Back then the filthy rich Republicans, owned garment shops, factories, foundries, tool/dies, right here in NYC--that's American soil. There was no EPA, yet,to shut down INDUSTRY, over a chip in a chimney brick! Where are those jobs, AXELROD? Can anyone say ACORN??"I smell a smelly rat, in da phat kat Union rank & file!" LOL MM.

Friday, December 7, 2012 at 6:26 AM


Forward we march - right off the cliff!

Friday, December 7, 2012 at 9:24 AM

George Rogers Clark in Ohio said:

Our very own anti-liberal missile: Michelle. BOOOOOM ! Another direct hit.

Thanks, Michelle. This is a great and informative piece.

Jimmie Hoffa's problems with A.G. Bobby Kennedy stemmed from buying and building Vegas hotels and casinos with union funds... sometimes by the method of loans to organized crime.

In my opinion, unions today are just as criminal in the manner in which they misuse member money without consent. More states should follow Wisconsin's lead and become "right to work" states. Some workers would still want their union, no matter what, but those with the ability to reason would leave. At least the unions would have less financial and political clout. (wait, those are the same forms of clout).

Friday, December 7, 2012 at 12:28 PM

Wayne in Hinesville, GA said:

Let's face it, unions have outlived theri usefulness. When they were advocating for a decent wage and better working conditions it made sense to most people. But now it has become nothing more than greed by the union leaders. They have managed to run manufacturing out of the country and were the biggest cause of the collapse of GM and Chrysler.

Friday, December 7, 2012 at 12:38 PM

George Rogers Clark in Ohio replied:

Agreed, Sarge. Like all forms of socialism, all power and capital gravitate to the party leaders who become the new wealthy elite being fed by the deceived workers who were promised "utopia" and got oppression instead.

Friday, December 7, 2012 at 1:55 PM

Mark E. Edmiston in Fullerton said:

HEY! IDIOTS! Wake up! These are the s-holes that are teaching your kids! This is the cr@p they are teaching your kids! And they are stealing your labor to support it! Slavery is the forceful taking of one's labor to benefit another!

Saturday, December 8, 2012 at 6:18 AM

Mark E. Edmiston in Fullerton said:

Why aren't these tax evaders going to prison... oh, never mind.

Saturday, December 8, 2012 at 6:24 AM