The Right Opinion

Obama's America Will Become Detroit

By Terence Jeffrey · Dec. 12, 2012

President Barack Obama travelled to Michigan this week and made his case for class war in defense of the welfare state.

We need to take more money from the rich, he said, or schools will not be able to afford books, students will not be able to afford college, and disabled children will not get health care.

“Our economic success has never come from the top down,” said Obama. “It comes from the middle out. It comes from the bottom up.”

Obama spoke these words a few miles from Detroit – the reductio ad absurdum of his argument.

If America continues down the road to Obama's America – a road that began when President Franklin Roosevelt started building a welfare state here – our entire nation will become Detroit.

Obama's economic and moral vision has played out in that city. What he seeks has been achieved there.

Last week, as reported by the Detroit Free Press, Michigan's state treasurer told Detroit's mayor and city council that the state may soon appoint an emergency financial manager for the city. Under Michigan law, the paper said, only such a manager can initiate the steps leading to a bankruptcy filing for the city.

By current calculations, Detroit faces obligations over the next six months that exceed its revenues by $47 million. The city, the Free Press reported, now pays $1.08 in benefits to municipal workers and retirees for every $1.00 it pays in salary.

What happened to Detroit? It is achieving socialism in one city.

Traditional two-parent families and the productive taxpaying citizens they produce have fled. In 1950, according the U.S. Census Bureau, Detroit had 1,849,568 people and was the fifth-largest city in the nation. By 2000, its population had dropped to 951,270; by 2010, to 713,777; and by 2011, to 706,585.

What has happened to the people who remain? The Census Bureau estimates there are 563,055 people age 16 or older in the city who could potentially work and be part of the labor force. But only 54.3 percent of these – or 305,479 individuals – actually do participate in the labor force, meaning they either have a job or are looking for one. Another 257,576 of Detroit residents age 16 or older – 45.7 percent of that demographic – do not participate in the labor force. They do not have a job, and they are not looking for one.

In fact, these 257,576 people in Detroit who do not have a job and are not looking for one outnumber the 224,846 residents who do have jobs. But of the 224,846 residents who do have jobs, 34,500 – or 15.3 percent – have jobs with the government. Thus, this city that boasted 1,849,568 residents in 1950 has only 190,346 private-sector workers today.

There are 264,209 households in Detroit, and 91,204 of them – or 34.5 percent – get food stamps.

Very few of the people who are staying out of the labor force in Detroit are staying out because they are stay-at-home moms with working husbands. Of the 264,209 households in Detroit, only 24,275 – or 9.2 percent – are married couple families with children under 18. Another 78,438 households – or 29.7 percent of the total – are “families” headed by women with no husband present. Of these, 43,742 have children under 18.

There were 12,103 babies born in Detroit in the 12 months prior to the Census Bureau survey, and 9,124 of them – or 75.4 percent – were born to unmarried women.

Of the 363,281 housing units in Detroit, 99,072 are vacant. Indeed, vacant houses have become a powerful visual symbol of what advancing socialism has done to the city. Traditional family life is nearing extinction in this once vibrant corner of America.

Obama said in Michigan that if the federal government does not take more money away from people who have earned it, the public schools may not be able to buy school books. But the Department of Education says that in the Detroit public schools – which have books – only 7 percent of the eight graders are grade-level proficient in reading and only 4 percent are grade-level proficient in math.

School books are not lacking here. Self-reliance, the spirit of individualism, and the Judeo-Christian values that support marriage and family are. They have been driven by a government that wants the people to depend on it rather than on themselves, their families and their faith.



wjm in Colorado said:

California will soon go the way of Detroit. Illinois is losing people too. The examples of Marxist Failure are many, the Democrats recognize the failure, but it is not their failure, they are in POWER, and living like royalty. The colapse is coming, chairman Obamao and his queen can enjoy their dictatorship for a while, but the end will come.

Wednesday, December 12, 2012 at 9:52 AM

P. Long in Texas replied:

It's not the Democrats failure, personally, is oh so right. Public records, published elsewhere on the net: The Net Worth of prominent Democrats:
Obama: $11.8 million
Nancy Pelosi: $26.4 million
Harry Reid: $2.6 million
Senator Kerry & wife Teresa: $200 million
George Clooney: $19 million (2010)
Bill (the mouth) Maher: $23 million
Jeaneane Garafalo: $10 million
This is only a sampling of our touchy feely Democrats and doesn't even include their 'one world government' cohorts.

Wednesday, December 12, 2012 at 2:15 PM

enemaofthestatistquo in Monroe, GA replied:

U know, Calipornia, & Illinoyance may not be losing people. They may have been Ordered by the Party Apparatus to infiltrate and destroy other States. Sometimes seems that way, much like we get People from all over the 3rd world who leave Totalitarian governments for a better life but pack their mother country's socialism in their suitcases to unpack here.

Wednesday, December 12, 2012 at 11:44 PM

Wayne in Hinesville, GA said:

Schools books aren't worth the paper they are printed if the students could care less if they get an education or not. Most of them go to school for free breakfast and lunch and to socialize. In this post-revisionist era what is being taught has little or nothing all to do with what made us a great nation. The education system is now on a blame America for almost every evil in the world. Like Mac says, these kids are being indoctrinated with a liberal mindset and could care less about our traditions.

Wednesday, December 12, 2012 at 11:08 AM

Alex Torello in New Haven said:

Sobering. A roadmap to disaster. Hard to argue with the facts--but no matter--liberals don't bother with facts.

Wednesday, December 12, 2012 at 11:41 AM

Kevin from Arkansas in USA said:

"Our economic success has never come from the top down," said Obama."

Nancy says the same: "Unemployment ... which probably are one of the most important stimuli for the economy.”

We've got plenty at the bottom so the economy ought to be roaring by now.

Wednesday, December 12, 2012 at 4:26 PM

Tod in Brooklyn, NY said:

The Tampa convention, was all about American individual success stories, but did any Socialist Democraps listen? Great empires were built with sweaty labor, prudence, and fossil fuels---NOT GOVERNMENT!!!

Wednesday, December 12, 2012 at 5:31 PM

enemaofthestatistquo in Monroe, GA replied:

Fossil fuels! gasp, Gasp, GASP. 8*)).

Wednesday, December 12, 2012 at 11:46 PM

Honest Abe in North Carolina said:

It might not be so final to say the United States will become Detroit. If things get bad in Detroit a resident could leave and find a better place somewhere else in the country. But, if the US goes down the hole where can anyone of us go for a better life? Detroit can always call upon the US producers to help them, but who can the US call upon to help us. It will not be the 51% who put that impious despot in office.

Saturday, December 15, 2012 at 5:10 PM