Progressives and Immigration Reform

· Friday, February 26, 2010

Immigration reform legislation is probably dead this year -- which, no doubt, pleases some conservatives. But the issue isn't going away. And if conservatives hope to become the dominant force in American politics, we need to figure out a way to resolve the problem without alienating the country's fastest growing demographic, Hispanics.

I delivered that message last week to some 10,000 conservatives gathered at the annual CPAC meeting in Washington. The message seemed to resonate among many in the audience -- a minority to be sure, but a fairly large one.

I wasn't surprised. Conservatives are not monolithic in their views on immigration policy, even if the media sometimes act as if anyone who favors immigration reform is a liberal -- or, in the increasingly popular buzzword, a progressive. To the contrary, I would argue that the real "progressives" in the immigration debate are the immigration restrictionists who offer nothing but Big Government/Big Brother solutions to the problem -- and those who favor market-based legal immigration are the true conservatives.

We've been here before. The Progressive Movement was instrumental in restricting immigration in the early 20th Century. Progressives believed in the ability to perfect society and its inhabitants. They promoted birth control, forced sterilization, and eugenics to weed out native-born "undesirables" and pushed for immigration restriction to keep out Italians, Jews, Poles, and others they deemed unfit to become Americans. Their shining achievement was the 1924 Immigration Act, which largely shut the door on immigration from southern and eastern Europe.

Today, groups like the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) and its research arm, the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS), are the inheritors of the Progressive Movement's anti-immigration mantle. John Tanton, who founded FAIR, CIS, Numbers USA and a plethora of other anti-immigration groups, is a self-described progressive who first became involved in public policy issues in the Sierra Club and Planned Parenthood, later becoming president of Zero Population Growth.

Like the earlier progressives, these immigration restrictionists believe that government regulation is the answer to almost everything. In 1986, they devised a plan to end illegal immigration by turning employers into gatekeepers and forcing every American who wants to hire a babysitter to be treated the same as a Fortune 500 company. And the whole scheme didn't work, as many of us warned at the time. More illegal immigrants have entered the country since the passage of the 1986 immigration bill than entered before it was passed.

But like the true progressives that they are, these restrictionists believe the problem can be fixed with more regulation. Now they want every American to carry an identification card that signifies he or she is eligible to work and they want every employer to seek permission from the federal government before hiring anyone. And they are perfectly content to establish huge government databases with information on every person who hopes to be employed -- and to trust that the information is 100 percent accurate and secure.

I'm sorry, but there is nothing conservative in that approach. It fairly reeks of the kind of hubris that is the hallmark of progressivism.

A true conservative approach to legal immigration reform is one that assumes government isn't any better at predicting future labor needs than it is at predicting the weather. True conservatism trusts individuals and the free market to make better decisions than government bureaucrats.

We need a legal immigration system that works -- one that allows the numbers of immigrants and temporary workers we admit to move up and down with the unemployment rate. But groups like FAIR and CIS don't want that. They want to virtually eliminate legal immigration (though they'll settle for reducing it by 90 percent) and they'd prefer a population about half the size of the current U.S. population, according to their own pronouncements over the years. Restricting immigration is only the first step in their progressive program to perfect America.

COPYRIGHT 2010 CREATORS.COM


Third-party content does not necessarily reflect the opinions of The Patriot Post.


Comments

oscar quintero

Your comments are apropos to the Hispanic dilemma in our nation. What is discouraging is that the Hispanic groups are not vocal enough to submit solutions that embrace the true value of conservative values.Instead, according to many Hispanic groups, the solution is for federal laws supporting immigration needs that are not in favor of foreign workers. What is needed, it seems to me, is for Hispanic groups to offer solutions to the immigration problems of the nation instead of demanding that the federal government enact rules for the solution of the problems.

Posted February 26, 2010 at 10:59:28 AM


TJS

Even Hispanics don't want amnesty. Anyone being honest realizes it rewards lawbreaking, and encourages massive continued illegal aliens.

Hispanics are overwhelmingly Democrat. They are conservative in values. They will always vote overwhelmingly Democrat.

We need to require state and local government to enforce immigration laws, instead of aiding and abetting. We need to crack down on businesses. It wouldn't take much for them to get the message and stop employing illegal. They are devastating construction employment of Americans.

We should beef up E-Verify to make it less porous, and to make use mandatory for all employers.

Glad to hear mention of immigration in this time of high unemployment. It is a castastrophe of 1.6 million new legal workers every year. The policy is insanely stupid.

It is time for the US to stop chain migration, aimed to please immigrant families but does nothing to benefit the US.

It is time to reduce the numbers coming in from millions per year to about 1/4 million. The US is growing way too fast, and the infrastructure cost is gigantic. We have grown 50% since 1970, and it looks like another 50% to 2050. That's crazy stupid.

Illegal alien criminal gang membership should be in itself a crime. We need to find a nice desert island for them, and plentiful life sentences. Those people are criminal parasites feeding on decent Americans, allowed by our lame government.

Posted February 27, 2010 at 7:26:27 PM


Milly

The tremendous influx of illegals into this country are having horrible consequences--California, for example, is bankrupt as are many of the hospitals that are having to close.. Every California family pays $1400 a year to suppport all the social programs and needs of the illegals...still it is not enough. A new school needs to open every day due to the needs of illegals' children. Their graduation rate from high school is dismal. They need to go back.We cannot afford them..It is bankrupting our country and putting our own citizens in danger from the many criminals who have sneaked in. If they are made legal, they get to bring millions more of their relatives in also.They are and will be taking jobs our own citizens desparately need. I say go back home and wait your turn. Stop bankrupting the U>S.

Posted February 28, 2010 at 5:48:37 PM


MichaelSSEC

"True conservatism trusts individuals and the free market to make better decisions than government bureaucrats."

Somebody might want to tell that to CNN, MSNBC, ABC, CBS, NBC, NPR, PBS and the clowns writing for the NY Times and WaPo. They seem to think Conservatives want every non-white worker in America rounded up and shot.

Frankly, I don't know ANY Conservatives who oppose LEGAL immigration. I've never even heard of one.

But what I have heard is that Leftist groups lobbying for various immigration reform measures are pushing for everything from amnesty to massive federal ID programs that would do little to stop illegal immigration but would place a serious burden on every American citizen and every American business. In fact, their proposals are uniformly harmful, such that one begins to wonder if their intentions have nothing at all to do with immigration and everything to do with an anti-American agenda to stifle our economy.

All of that is totally pointless because immigration isn't that complicated. I heard a speaker who described a newly-arrived immigrant who got a minimum-wage job at a factory. The man seemed happy since the pay rate was still much higher than he could earn in Mexico. Several months later the speaker visited the same factory and asked to speak the immigrant again. This time, the immigrant told a very different story. During the intervening weeks, he had been doing menial jobs, but noticed the company paid a premium for contract maintenance on their forklifts. The immigrant had years of experience with jackleg repairs on lots of different machinery -- he could fix almost anything. He offered his bosses a way to save a lot of money on repairs. So now instead of earning minimum wage, he was making $22/hr. The best part, said the immigrant, was that now he did not need to stay at the factory if he became unhappy there; he could make $22/hr anywhere.

That's immigration. Conservatives LOVE stories like that because that's how we see the American Dream. You come to America, work hard and move up. You don't stay in a menial position for low pay very long. In a few years you're assimilated and maybe you can open your own business. That's what we Conservatives call SUCCESS.

Leftist groups would view the immigrant as a victim, offer him welfare and food stamps, maybe some basic education in Spanish, and he'd be working right around minimum wage all his life because he'd have no incentive to better himself. Years after coming here, ESL programs would insure his English was just as bad as when he arrived.

Yet the Left and the media demonizes Conservatives as the bad guys in the immigration debate. They're pretty good at it too. But who does more good for more immigrants -- and for America?

Posted February 28, 2010 at 8:29:21 PM


Post a Comment

Please keep comments civil and brief. Obscene, profane, abusive and off-topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked.

(required, displayed)
(required, not displayed)
Facebook Twitter YouTube RSS Connect with The Patriot Post






Our Mission

To Support and Defend -- Read The Patriot Post -- It's Right. It's Free. -- www.patriotpost.us

"The Patriot's mission is to advocate for Essential Liberty, the restoration of constitutional limits on government and the judiciary, and to promote free enterprise, national defense and traditional American values. Our objective is to provide Patriots across our nation with a touchstone of First Principles through brief, informative and entertaining analyses of relevant news, policy and opinion from reputable research, advocacy and media organizations, so they may better support and defend those Principles, and enlist others to join our ranks." —Mark Alexander, Publisher


The Patriot Post is not sustained by any political, special interest or parent organization, and we accept no advertising. Our mission and operations are funded entirely by the voluntary financial support of Patriots like you!

Support The 2012 Patriot Fund