Voters in Maryland just reelected Democrat Governor Wes Moore by a significant margin of more than two to one. Moore’s popularity, combined with his minority status — he is a black man — has led folks to see him as a potential 2028 presidential candidate for Democrats.

However, one significant issue could derail Moore’s ambitions of winning the Democrat nomination: his military record. Or, more specifically, his past claims regarding his military record.

The accusation, which appears to have merit, is that Moore embellished his military record by claiming he received a Bronze Star for his Army service in Afghanistan when he applied for a White House fellowship in 2006.

In 2024, it was exposed that he had not received a Bronze Star. Moore claimed that his friend and superior officer, then Lt. Col. Michael Fenzel, had told him at the time that he would receive the medal; however, Moore asserted he didn’t receive it because “the paperwork never processed,” joking, “because paperwork issues never happen in the Army, let’s be clear.”

Then, in 2024, after this story came to light, Moore was retroactively given the Bronze Star. So, 18 years later, the military finally corrected its paperwork-processing mistake... or did it?

Well, according to retired Lt. Col. James A. Gottschling, Moore’s direct supervisor during his tour in Afghanistan, the Bronze Star medal claim is bogus.

Gottschling said, “Right now Moore has two awards for the same period of time, and you can’t have that.”

Photographic evidence appears to support Gottschling’s claim. Recently, a series of photos from a March 1, 2006, end-of-tour award ceremony in Afghanistan surfaced, showing Moore receiving the Army Commendation Medal.

Indeed, Moore receiving the lesser medal makes more sense, as he fulfilled only six months of the 11-month counterinsurgency mission because he arrived five months late. Furthermore, others like Moore, who served only part of the Combine Task Force Devil, also received an Army Commendation Medal. That is not to diminish that service, but to put it in proper context.

The photos also show several soldiers being awarded the Bronze Star in that same ceremony. A photo shows then-Col. Patrick Donahue pinning a Combat Action Badge on Moore in recognition of his presence at an “indirect fire” rocket attack at the base in 2005.

All this evidence suggests that Moore’s “paperwork processing” error claim is dubious.

Gottschling further notes, “If anything, the Army Commendation Medal that he received in 2006 should have been recommended for upgrade to a Bronze Star, but that’s a completely different process.” He also points out what the rules mandate: “Only one decoration will be awarded to an individual or unit for the same act, achievement, or period of meritorious service.”

Moore also appears to play up his combat experience. When asked in a recent interview with Chuck Todd to clarify if he ever was in a firefight, he answered “Yes” and added rather sneakily, “It’s all been documented. And people who I’ve actually, you know, again, I’ve received the Combat Action Badge.”

Gottschling found Moore’s embellishment of his tour in Afghanistan offensive, especially given the fact that he and others “got orders to go to Iraq a year and a half later.” He explained, “We started getting new people, new training, this stuff to get ready to go into another combat arena. Moore just kind of dipped in and dipped out, and then he’s telling these overembellished stories about seeing combat, which didn’t happen.”

He also responded to Moore’s claims over the years that he “led soldiers in combat” in Afghanistan. Gottschling said, “It’s disingenuous to say ‘I’m a paratrooper, I led troops into combat,’” adding, “He wanted to emotionalize and aggrandize his activities. It just wasn’t true, and I just couldn’t sit here and be a party to this.”

If Moore does run for president in 2028, his military record and apparent embellishments will be further scrutinized. The question is whether it will matter to enough voters. It should.