A recent Guardian article titled “Why Tradwives Are Fleeing the Movement” shares the stories of several former tradwives who once embraced rigid gender roles and promoted them as the ideal model of Christian marriage. Now, after describing years of abuse and control, these women have rejected the lifestyle they once championed and are warning others not to follow in their footsteps.

Looking back, they reflect on the warning signs they missed and how their understanding of traditional marriage contributed to years of hardship. The article uses their experiences to raise broader concerns about the tradwife movement, while the women themselves warn of the dangers of idealizing extreme gender roles.

The key word is “extreme.”

Their stories are disturbing and absolutely worth hearing. But the problem lies in the broader narrative the writer tries to push: that abusive husbands are somehow representative of conservative Christian men, and that extreme religious control is synonymous with traditional family values.

The article’s opening directly ties the rise of the tradwife movement to Donald Trump’s first presidency and the growing interest in traditional family values. It further suggests that MAGA’s vision for women is one of male control and oppression, even highlighting some of these women’s support for Brett Kavanaugh’s Supreme Court nomination. The strong implication is that conservative values include defending men accused of sexual misconduct. Kavanaugh was accused, of course, but the allegations weren’t credible.

By portraying these women’s experiences as a reflection of what conservatives really mean when they advocate for traditional values, the goal seems less about giving a voice to women who have suffered and more about using their hardships to discredit traditional marriage altogether. Rather than encouraging understanding, it aims to deepen the divide between men and women, and between conservative Christian women and modern feminists.

The first story centers on Bernadine Bluntly, a former tradwife influencer. She has since spoken out about what she alleges was an abusive marriage that ultimately ended in divorce.

In an Instagram video titled “What I Got Wrong About the Trad Movement,” Bluntly publicly rejected the rigid gender roles she once championed. While she remains a Christian who believes men and women are different by design, she says she “no longer believes in extreme gender roles, especially when they’re wrapped in spiritual language and used to justify control, silence, or harm.”

And that’s an important message — and conservative Christian women can wholeheartedly recognize and agree with it.

There’s nothing inherently oppressive about women choosing motherhood, homemaking, or a traditional division of responsibilities. Those choices can lead to incredibly healthy, fulfilling lives. The problem begins when traditional values are misinterpreted as an excuse to control another person — something that women and men who truly understand these values would never encourage.

Another woman featured is Jennie Gage, who grew up in a traditional Latter-day Saint family and spent 24 years raising five children. According to Gage, her husband prohibited her from working or having her own bank account, leaving her financially vulnerable when their marriage ended.

In a video discussing her experience, Gage recalls feeling trapped, exhausted, and isolated. Her ultimate realization? “A man is not a plan.”

She’s right that women need financial security, and being excluded from family financial decisions can leave them vulnerable.

So, the problem wasn’t Gage’s decision to stay home and raise children, but her husband’s alleged use of financial dependence to control her. Both feminists and conservative Christians can agree that choosing motherhood shouldn’t mean sacrificing financial security.

Millions of couples have successfully built families with one spouse earning an income while the other manages the home and raises children. That arrangement works when both contributions are valued, and both spouses have access to the family’s financial resources.

However, the Left’s broader implication remains: Traditional family values supposedly serve a political agenda to oppress women, diminish their worth, and limit their role in society. These women’s controlling, abusive relationships supposedly represent what conservative Christian women want for themselves, their daughters, and all American women.

That’s a pretty sweeping suggestion to make about millions of women. But is there evidence that this is the life that MAGA or conservative Christians in general want for women?

The conservative movement is full of women who raise families and build successful careers.

Karoline Leavitt became White House press secretary at the start of President Trump’s second term, just months after giving birth to her first son. She quickly became known for her confidence and command of the briefing room, fielding tough questions and keeping the American public informed, all while raising a young family. Even after the birth of her second child, she balanced motherhood with long workdays in one of the country’s most high-profile positions.

She eventually chose to step away from the position to focus on her family, but she demonstrated that women can pursue ambitious careers while raising children, and that conservative Christians support that across the board. She also showed that fulfilling your dreams doesn’t necessarily mean doing everything at once. Sometimes, it simply means being willing to adjust your priorities during different seasons of life.

Leavitt isn’t alone. Sarah Huckabee Sanders raised three children while serving as White House press secretary before becoming governor of Arkansas. Kayleigh McEnany balanced motherhood with one of the most demanding communications jobs in Washington, while Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett built an extraordinary legal career as a mother of seven.

These women openly embrace their Christian faith and family values while holding influential positions. They demonstrate that pursuing traditional marriage and motherhood doesn’t mean sacrificing ambition, independence, or a meaningful role in society.

When conservative Christians call for a return to traditional family values, they’re advocating for strong homes built on dedicated mothers and fathers — the foundation of a healthy, thriving society. That doesn’t mean restricting women, and supporting Trump certainly doesn’t mean believing men should have complete authority over women.

That’s why it’s important to distinguish traditional values from their misuse. The women featured in The Guardian offer important warnings about abuse, financial control, and religious manipulation. But their experiences don’t mean traditional Christian values are inherently oppressive.

Harmful expectations aren’t exclusive to extreme interpretations of a Christian lifestyle. Just as teaching young women that marriage requires complete submission can leave them vulnerable, teaching them that careers and financial independence can replace marriage and motherhood creates its own unrealistic expectations.

The extremes of modern feminism have just as much potential to mislead women about what it takes to build a happy, fulfilling life. Perhaps that’s where conservative Christian women and feminists can find common ground.

We can agree that women deserve safety, dignity, financial security, and the freedom to build meaningful lives. We can condemn abusive marriages without condemning traditional values, just as we can celebrate professional success without diminishing motherhood.

Ultimately, women shouldn’t have to choose between a career without a family and a marriage without independence.

True empowerment means being honest with women, not pressuring them to conform — whether to a controlling spouse’s distorted view of marriage or a feminist ideology that discourages motherhood and portrays the sacrifices of family life as a loss of identity.