“Before the midterms this month,” begins The New York Times’s Emily Bazelon, “experts who measure the health of democracies saw the United States experiencing ‘the most dramatic decline in American history,’ in the words of one global index.”

Alas, what would we do without “experts”? And what would we do without experts who cite dramatic declines in global indexes? And what would we do without New York Times reporters who lead with lazy appeals to authority by citing experts citing dramatic declines in global indexes?

The global index in question, the 2026 V-DEM Democracy Report, is produced by true-believing globalists within the Political Science Department at Sweden’s University of Gothenburg. And I don’t know about you, but when I think of experts in the field of American democratic collapse, I definitely tend to think of European academics.

First things first, though: Our American democracy — it’s a republic, but whatever — was never in danger. At least not from Donald Trump. To be sure, it was in danger when Big Tech leftists were colluding with Democrats and the FBI and the CIA to trample the First Amendment rights of American citizens and news organizations, and thereby interfering in our presidential elections, but then Elon Musk plopped down $44 billion and bought Twitter and released The Twitter Files.

Yet to hear the “experts” tell it, we were practically Saddam’s Iraq until the American people rose up on November 3 and took their country back from the brink. “Steven Levitsky at Harvard University says the regime in the USA is now some type of authoritarianism,” the report grimly notes before shrieking, “The Century Foundation argues that ‘American democracy is already collapsing.’” Like all foundations, the Century Foundation is shot through with leftists, but at least it has a sense of oxymoronic humor. As the About page notes, “The Century Foundation is a progressive, independent think tank.”

Tellingly, the 52-page report uses the word “democracy” 408 times and the word “democracies” an additional 87 times, but it uses the words “republic” and “republics” exactly zero times, except when referring to proper-name countries like the Dominican Republic and the Central African Republic. In fairness, the index does mention the word “Republican” four times, though — each in lament of Trump’s Republican Party “endorsing a far-right, nationalist, and anti-pluralist agenda,” and having “abdicated its constitutional role in favor of the executive branch.”

As for Bazelon’s article, she moves quickly from international Chicken Littleism to the domestic variety: “Warnings also came from judges ruling on election-related cases. In late October, Judge David O. Carter blocked the Justice Department from ordering California officials to segregate the ballots of 20,000 voters who were on a list of suspected noncitizens that Carter found to be unreliable. ‘If the executive can discount votes and threaten an ongoing election due to unproven allegations, then our democracy is in danger,’ he wrote.”

As the once-great George Will once said: Well. And as the never-even-remotely-great yours truly more than once said: “[Insert judge’s name here] is a [insert former Democrat president’s name here] appointee.”

Indeed, whenever I need a second opinion on a European university’s assessment of the state of American “democracy,” I tend to consult octogenarian Clinton-appointed judges.

Bazelon continues, “Against the backdrop of such fears, the November election became not just a referendum on President Trump, but also a crucial test of American democracy. In the end, the country passed. Turnout was the second highest for a midterm in more than a century, and Republicans, including Trump, have accepted the results.”

So you see, the midterms weren’t just a test; they were a “crucial test.” And American “democracy” passed this “crucial test” by electing Democrats.

If we take a trip down memory lane, though, we find that the mainstream media had a decidedly different view of the wisdom of the American electorate. As The Washington Post’s Sarah Ellison wrote after Trump’s resounding 2024 victory:

Those who study democracy say that the most alarming element of America’s version of it has been a breakdown of the checks and balances designed to keep it healthy. The ultimate check was supposed to be the voters, and “that guardrail failed spectacularly,” said Sarah Churchwell, a professor of American literature and the chair of public understanding of the humanities at the University of London.

Again with the international perspective. But notice: When the American people elect Democrats, American democracy passes a “crucial test.” But when the American people elected Trump, America’s “guardrail failed spectacularly.”

“Does one free and fair election mean the concerns that preceded it were overblown?” asks Bazelon. Not necessarily, she warns, “But the election suggests that American democracy has the resources to heal.” Whew.

“Maybe Trump will be remembered,” Bazelon concludes, “for trying to distort American democracy but ultimately proving that it was stronger than him.”

Uh-huh. But it’s a republic, Emily. A republic, if we can keep it.