To many young folks, the American Dream seems further out of reach than it did in recent decades. They’re angry, and many of them are ready to burn down the system.
In the last election, they voted Democrat, which may be basically the same thing.
Socialism or anything approaching it won’t fix the system. In fact, increasing government control and redistribution of income is why the system has problems. Doing it even harder obviously isn’t the solution.
Alas, young people are educated in public schools that teach hatred of America. But that’s another story.
On the subject of the American Dream, an intense debate has broken out on the Right — including in our editorial meeting this morning — on the best way to look at things. Perhaps it started with Kat Timpf on Fox News’s “Gutfeld!” I’ll quote her observations at length:
I recognize that affordability issues are real, but I don’t think the Democrats are going to solve the problem. ... Just because there’s a coordinated effort to point them out doesn’t mean they’re not real. Again, not all Trump’s fault. Don’t think that the Democrats are going to be able to solve them. But prices are still rising faster than pay. Gas is still $1 more than it was this time last year. GDP is up, but people are spending, not saving. And there are cost issues, particularly for younger Americans. Housing is a great example of that. It’s just a fact that it’s harder to buy a house now than it used to be. ...
The average [first-time] homebuyer is 40, which does impede people.
The average starter home in 242 cities is a million dollars. So it is harder for younger people. Now this is the message that Trump ran on in 2024. He ran on affordability. You’re feeling left behind. I’m here for you. I think Trump’s message won in the midterms. It just wasn’t Republicans delivering it. ...
Home prices used to be about three times median income. Now they’re about four to five times — in some areas, six to 10. It doesn’t mean you didn’t work hard. It doesn’t mean your generation didn’t work hard. These are just the facts, and this is why Republicans didn’t win at an age group younger than 65-plus. ... Socialism is not the answer to this. Part of the reason things are more expensive is government. But telling people that they’re not feeling what they’re feeling in their own real lives — it’s clearly not a way to win voters.
Note: For the claim about 242 cities, Timpf used a Zillow report from June. Meanwhile, between 2019 and 2024, the average price of a starter home increased an eye-popping 54%. Long gone are those 3% interest rates, too.
If you’re wondering, Timpf is 38, which puts her squarely in the Millennial generation. Show host Greg Gutfeld is 62, the youngest of the Boomer generation, and he argued against her, essentially saying, You kids just need to quit complaining and work harder. It’s the latest entry in the generally nasty and bitter Boomer vs. Millennial debate.
I’m a decade older than Timpf (Gen X), and some of my Gen Z children are now out in the workforce and thinking about buying homes. They find it daunting, but they’re pushing forward with financial planning to make it happen like my wife and I did in our 20s.
That is the American Dream. Working hard toward realizing your aspirations.
The American Dream is not electing politicians who promise to take money from someone else so you can get a sliver of it, all while they never honestly tell you of the dependency they’re creating.
As for whether the dream is reachable, both “sides” have great arguments.
Yes, younger folks tend to expect more handouts, swayed by the influencers they watch on their $1,300 iPhones. As fellow Gen Xer Mark Hemingway put it, “It is true that when boomers bought their own homes 40 years ago, they were better savers and didn’t spend $500 a month on DoorDash and subscription services.” In many respects, if young people would quit complaining and work harder, they’d find that success is still achievable. Boomers fought to make it during a time of immense inflationary pressure, outrageously high interest rates, gas lines and shortages, and the Jimmy Carter malaise. They did it, and young people can too.
Ben Shapiro makes a similar argument at The Daily Wire. Perhaps that’s easy for him to say — the 42-year-old is worth millions after building a media empire. But he’s also right that hard work, ingenuity, and entrepreneurship can pay off. He grew up lower middle class and turned his efforts into a fortune. Try that in some socialist backwater.
He’s also absolutely right when he says, “Your life is in your own hands.” A victim mentality never helped anyone but Democrat politicians.
On the other hand, younger folks are also right, as Timpf ably explained. Boomers are the richest generation in history, and they bought homes on blue-collar wages. Few members of Gen Z can hope to do likewise when even renting an apartment takes up half their income and the only available homes are being sold by Boomers banking on inflated values. Young folks are competing for jobs in a market with fewer factory positions and more high-skill jobs, and they’re doing so against a flood of cheap, illegal labor and the rise of AI.
It’s not as simple as “quit complaining and work harder.” And it’s definitely not as simple as electing Democrats — the party of job-killing minimum wage hikes, higher taxes, onerous regulations, and inflationary government spending — to fix it. President Donald Trump strayed from his economic message, but that doesn’t mean Democrats will help anyone with affordability.
And who would trust a party that hates America and blames it for everything from inequality to racism to climate change to restore the American Dream?
Well, voters, apparently — especially younger ones, who went 35 points for Democrats. But as Hemingway argues, “When [making the] case begins and ends with telling anyone under 40 that they’re too weak and undisciplined to enjoy the economic security previous generations took for granted, well, that’s a good way to ensure Republicans keep losing elections.”
We advocates of American Liberty and the American Dream have our work cut out for us. Which, come to think of it, seems kind of fitting.








