Can Biden Buy Votes With Student Debt Relief?
The Democrats’ political situation, with less than seven months to Election Day, is that the party is losing support among young voters.
The 2020 Democratic presidential primary race was a bidding war in which the various candidates advocated spending trillions of dollars to enact sweeping progressive agendas. Some agendas were a bit more sweeping than others, but they all amounted to unprecedented increases in federal spending.
Take the issue of student loans. Sen. Bernie Sanders, the most progressive of the contenders, wanted to cancel all $1.6 trillion in student debt — just throw out all student loans for 40-plus million people and somehow make Wall Street pay for it. Sen. Elizabeth Warren pledged to forgive everyone’s student loans up to $50,000. And President Joe Biden, the most cautious of the bunch, promised to “forgive a minimum of $10,000 per person of federal student loans.”
But here’s the thing. It didn’t happen, and yet no person with student loan debt has had to make a payment, any payment, for more than two years. It is all in the name of COVID relief. And it is still going on.
It started in the Trump administration. When Congress passed the first COVID relief bill, in March 2020, it paused student loan payments until September of that year. Then-President Donald Trump extended the pause until Dec. 31, 2020. Then the Trump administration extended it again, through the end of January 2021, by which time Biden would be president.
Since then, even as he touted the improving economy — the job market is hot these days — Biden has extended the loan repayment pause time after time. On April 6, a couple of weeks ago, he did it again. “If loan payments were to resume on schedule in May,” Biden said in a statement, “analysis of recent data from the Federal Reserve suggests that millions of student loan borrowers would face significant economic hardship, and delinquencies and defaults could threaten Americans’ financial stability.”
So Biden extended the pause through Aug. 31, 2022. Now, here’s a question: Does anyone believe he will let payments resume at any point before this year’s midterm elections?
The same progressives who pushed for student loan forgiveness in the 2020 campaign are still pushing for it today. The problem is that they know they can’t pass such a measure through Congress. So they have been urging Biden to use his executive authority, in a way that would surely bring a constitutional challenge, to forgive student debt all by himself.
Meanwhile, the nation has a sort of backdoor loan forgiveness policy in place in the form of a continuously renewed moratorium on payments. Those 2020 Democratic campaign promises have (sort of) been kept — there will be no student loan repayments from the presidential election through the midterm elections.
And possibly even beyond that. Discussing the president’s extension on a Democratic podcast, White House press secretary Jen Psaki said Biden would extend the pause yet again — if he doesn’t make a decision about canceling some debt altogether. “Between now and Aug. 31, it’s either going to be extended or we’re going to make a decision,” Psaki said.
There’s no doubt why Biden is doing it. He has concerns about the president’s authority to cancel student debt. But he has no problem extending the moratorium started by his predecessor. And if he extends it just a little longer, no one will be resuming loan payments right as the midterm elections arrive. All of which prompted Betsy DeVos, who was Trump’s education secretary, to tweet, “The White House should just be honest about what they’re doing and announce they’ll turn the loan portfolio on after Election Day.” Don’t look for that to happen.
But what about the merits of all this? Biden’s handling of student debt is “galactically stupid,” in the words of Douglas Holtz-Eakin, a former head of the Congressional Budget Office. For several reasons. One, it’s “a misuse of pandemic emergency authorities,” Holtz-Eakin said, since it has “nothing to do with COVID-19.” Two, it’s “a misreading of the economy.” The job market is “incredibly tight,” giving workers a lot of flexibility. “If people who have gone to college cannot get a job and make loan payments now, what does it take to end the deferral?” asked Holtz-Eakin.
Third, it’s expensive and is “money spent with no return.” And finally, according to Holtz-Eakin, it is “throwing money at the affluent.” “It has been more than adequately documented that benefits of student loan deferral and forgiveness disproportionately accrue to the more affluent,” Holtz-Eakin wrote. “One can claim that they have ‘significant economic hardship,’ and that payment threatens ‘financial stability,’” two arguments from Biden’s April 6 statement, “but the facts don’t support it.”
But the politics do. And the Democrats’ political situation, with less than seven months to Election Day, is that the party is losing support among young voters. Democrats face the double problem of possible low turnout among young voters and still others abandoning the party — on top of the other groups leaving the party, too.
All that just four years after a big midterm performance. “The strong across-the-board turnout in the 2018 midterm election appears to be an outlier,” noted Democratic analyst Ed Kilgore. “The election was basically a referendum on Donald Trump, whom younger voters really disliked. Second, while under-30 voters are not a ripe target for the Trump-era GOP, they aren’t very fond of Joe Biden, either.” Biden’s support among voters ages 18 to 34, around 40%, is “quite low for such a pro-Democratic group,” Kilgore added.
How to score points with them? How about canceling student loan debt? Or, failing that, extending the moratorium on having to pay off student loan debt? A headline in the New Republic says: “Biden’s Only Good Pre-Midterm Play: Cancel Student Debt; Biden is in the low 40s, and young voters are disillusioned. There’s one obvious way to reignite a little enthusiasm. Will he take it?”
Maybe he will. But even if Biden does not actually cancel debt, he can extend the payment moratorium as long as he wants — all the way to the 2024 presidential election, if it comes to that. The president and his party desperately need young voters, who probably won’t be interested enough to turn out this November. Look for him to do anything to get their attention.
This content originally appeared on the Washington Examiner at washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/can-biden-buy-votes-with-student-debt-relief.
(Byron York is chief political correspondent for The Washington Examiner.)
Start a conversation using these share links: